Value Comparison
Carvalu.com™ Novel Comparison Chart
Carvalu.com™ SCROLL DOWN COMPARISON CHART WITH ROUNDED DOLLAR FIGURES (*) Copyright 1988-2010 Tommy Vig --Group One of Five Please see Important Notes at the bottom of Group Five of Five | ||||
Kia Sportage 2wd 2dr conv. | Toyota RAV4 Soft Top 2wd 2dr | Jeep Cherokee S 2wd 2dr | Isuzu Rodeo S 2wd 4dr | |
Retail Price (MSRP) | $14,000 | $15,700 | $16,000 | $18,200 |
Wholesale Price (Invoice) | $12,700 | $14,300 | $15,100 | $17,100 |
Destination Charge | $450 | $420 | $520 | $500 |
Dealer Hold Back (Approximate) | $0 | $300 | $480 | $550 |
Value Per Professionals' Consensus (**) (+ / -) | $14,960=+ $960 | $14,970=[-$730] | $15,200=[-$800] | $17,390=[-$810] |
"Honest" Base Price ™ (***) - Rating / Rank | $12,110 (13.5% disadvantage -$1,890) / 16th | $11,450 (27% disadvantage -$4,250) / 20th | $14,120 (12% disadvantage -$1,880) / 17th | $16,270 (10.5% disadvantage -$1,930) / 15th |
YOUR VALUE™ ~ see interactive WIP pie | ||||
TRUE VALUE™ ~ see interactive WIP pie | ||||
I. PERFORMANCE | ||||
0-60 mph acceleration (seconds) | 11.0 | 12.8 | 12.0 | 9.4 |
Acceleration - Rating / Rank | 10.4% slower than average / 16th | 28.5% slower than average / 20th | 20.5% slower than average / 17th | 5.6 % quicker than average / 10th |
All Wheel Drive | no | no | no | no |
"Attitude" | More Truck-like | More Truck-like | More Truck-like | More Truck-like |
Cylinders | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 |
Cylinders- Rating / Rank | 29.8% less than average / tied for 14th (w/6) | 29.8% less than average / tied for 14th (w/6) | 29.8% less than average / tied for 14th (w/6) | 29.8% less than average / tied for 14th (w/6) |
Displacement in Cubic Inches (ci) | 122 | 122 | 150 | 134 |
Displacement - Rating / Rank | 43.6% smaller than avg / tied for 18th (w/2) | 43.6% smaller than avg / tied for 18th (w/2) | 30.7% smaller than average / 15th | 38.1% smaller than average / 17th |
Engine Location / Drive Wheels | front / rear | front / front | front / rear | front / rear |
Engine Type | 2.0L I4 | 2.0L I4 | 2.5L I4 | 2.2L I4 |
EPA Classification | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD |
4-Wheel Drive | no | no | no | no |
Fuel Delivery System | MPFI | SEFI | SEFI | SEFI |
Ground Clearance (inches) | 7.9 | 7.5 | 8.1 | 7.1 |
Handling and Driveability - Rating / Rank | 6.8% below average / 16th | 15.7% better than average / tied for 3rd | 1.2% better than average / tied for 8th (w/2) | 1.2% better than average / tied for 8th (w/2) |
Horsepower | 130 | 127 | 125 | 130 |
Horsepower - Rating / Rank | 29.8% less than average / tied for 17th | 31.4% less than average / 19th | 32.5% less than average / 20th | 29.8% less than average / tied for 17th |
Maximum Allowable Weight | 4,156 lbs. | 3,550 lbs. | 4,550 lbs. | 4,550 |
Maximum Allowable Weight Rating / Rank | 17.8% less than average / tied for 18th | 29.8% less than average / 20th | 10% less than average / tied for 12th | 10% less than average / tied for 12th |
Off Road Ability - Rating / Rank | 22.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/3) | 47.5% below average / tied for 18th (w/2) | 5.1% better than average / tied for 9th (w/2) | 40.1% better than average / tied for 3rd |
Overall Performance - Rating / Rank | 21.6% better than average / tied for 13th | 37.3% better than average / tied for 3rd | 2% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/2) | 41.2% worse than avg / tied for 15th (w/5) |
Payload (lbs.) | 838 | 1004 | 1151 | 1049 |
Payload Rating / Rank | 33.7% below average / 19th | 20.6% below average / 15th | 9% below average / 11th | 17% below average / 14th |
Reviewers' Recommendation - Rating / Rank | 28% less than avg / 19th | 28% more than avg / tied for 3rd | 20% less than avg / tied for 12th (w/3) | 23% less than avg / tied for 16th |
Standard Transmission | 4 speed auto | 5 speed manual | 5 speed manual | 5 speed manual |
Steering | recirc | rack & pinion | recirc | rack & pinion |
Stroke | 86 | 86.1 | n/p (not published) | 94.6 |
Suspension (Front / Rear) | independent / independent | independent/independent | live / live | independent / live |
Top Speed | 93 mph | 98 mph | 93 mph | 109 mph |
Top Speed-Rating / Rank | 15.1% less than average / tied for 20th | 10.6% less than average / 17th | 15.1% slower than average / tied for 19th | 0.5% slower than average / tied for 12th |
Torque | 127@4,000 | 132 @ 4,600 | 150 @ 3,250 | 144 @ 4,000 |
Tow Capacity / Hauling (lbs.) | 2,000 | 1,500 | 2,000 | 2,500 |
Tow Capacity / Hauling-Rating / Rank | 43.7% less than average / tied for 14th (w/3) | 57.7% less than average / tied for 18th | 43.7% less than average / tied for 14th (w/3) | 29.6% less than average / 13th |
Trailering Equipment | no | no | no | no |
Transmission Quality - Rating / Rank | 28.1% worse than average / 20th | 13.7% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/6) | 13.7% worse than average / tied for 13th (w/6) | 0.7% better than average / tied for 9th (w/3) |
Valves | 16 | 16 | 8 | 16 |
Valves - Rating / Rank | 3.2% more than average / tied for 4th (w/8) | 3.2% more than average / tied for 4th (w/8) | 48.4% less than average / 20th | 3.2% more than average / tied for 4th (w/8) |
Weight Distribution Front / Rear | 56 / 44 | 61 / 39 | 52 / 48 | n/p |
II. RELIABILITY | ||||
Battery - Rating / Rank | 520 | 325 | 500 | 600 |
Battery Amps | 5.2% less than average / tied for 12th (w/4) | 40.6% less than average / 20th | 8.9% less than average / 17th | 9.4% more than average / tied for 6th (w/2) |
Cold Climate Package | no | no | no | no |
Frequency of Repair - Rating / Rank | 27.8 % worse than average / tied for 19th | 31.9% better than average / 1st | 27.8 % worse than average / tied for 19th | 23.6% worse than average / tied for 17th |
General- Rating / Rank | 5% worse than avg / tied for 13th | 15% better than avg / 2nd | 4% worse than avg / tied for 10th ( w/2) | 28% worse than avg / 20th |
Number of Complaints - Rating / Rank | 139.7% more (worse) than avg / 20th | 57.5% less (better) than avg / tied for 7th | 34,2% less (better) than avg / 11th | 40% more (worse) than avg / 13th |
Model Year of Production | 5th | 4th | 16th | 2nd |
Recalls - Rank | 17th | 16th | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) |
Reputation of Manufacturer - Rating / Rank | 37.5% worse than average / 20th | 25% better than average / tied for 3rd | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 21.9% worse than average / tied for 17th |
III. SAFETY | ||||
60 mph-0 Braking Distance (feet) | 164 | 130 | 157 | 138 |
60 mph-0 Braking Distance - Rating / Rank | 8.8% longer (worse) than average / 17th | 13.7% shorter (better) than average / 1st | 4.2% longer (worse) than average / tied for 15th | 8.4% shorter (better) than average / tied for 3rd |
Anti-lock Brake System (ABS) | no | n/p | no | yes |
Auto Leveling Suspension System | n/p | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Brakes (Front / Rear) | disc / drum | disc / drum | disc / drum | disc / drum |
Brake Quality - Rating / Rank | 23.3% worse than average / tied for 20th | 7.4% better than average / 6th | 23.3% worse than average /tied for 20th | 23.3% worse than average / tied for 20th |
Bumper Strength | n/p | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Cargo Net | no | no | no | no |
Curb Weight (lbs.) | 3,108 | 2,547 | 3,017 | 3,495 |
Curb Weight Rank | 17.6% less than average / 18th | 32% less than average / 20th | 20% less than average / 19th | 7.4% less than average / 15th |
Day / Night Rear View Mirror | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Daylight Running Lights | no | no | no | no |
Driver Air Bag | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Dual Note Horn | no | no | no | no |
First Aid Kit | no | no | no | no |
Fog Lights | no | no | no | no |
Front, Back, & Side Visibility - Rating / Rank | 0.9% better than average / tied for 10th (w/6) | 20.7% worse than average / 18th | 0.9% better than average / tied for 10th (w/6) | 0.9% better than average / tied for 10th (w/6) |
Global Position / Navigation System (GPS) | no | no | no | no |
Halogen Headlights | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Height (inches) | 65 | 65.4 | 63.8 | 66.1 |
Insurance Company Rating / Rank | 21.9% worse than average / tied for 9th (w/8) | 21.9% worse than average / tied for 9th (w/8) | 56.3% better than average / tied for 1st (w/7) | 21.9% worse than average / tied for 9th (w/8) |
Length (inches) | 156.9 | 147.6 | 167.5 | 176.7 |
Maneuverability - Rating / Rank | 6.4% worse than average / tied for 14th | 9.2% better than average / tied for 4th (w/7) | 9.2% better than average / tied for 4th (w/7) | 37.6% worse than average / tied for 18th |
NHTSA, etc. Frontal Crash Test Results-R/R | 22.4% worse than avg / tied for 16th (w/2) | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) | 22.4% worse than average / tied for 16th (w/2) | 6.8% worse than average / 15th |
Occupant Injury Statistics Rating | 82.4% worse than average / 20th | 47.3% worse than average / 19th | 12.1% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/4) | n/p |
Overall Size - Rating / Rank | 9.1% smaller than average / 19th | 12.2% smaller than average / 20th | 5.6% smaller than average / 18th | 1.7% smaller than average / 13th |
Passenger Air Bag | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Brakes | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Reverse Sensing System | no | no | no | no |
Road Holding Index | n/p | 0.70 | 0.70 | n/p |
Road Holding Index - Rating / Rank | n/p | 1.4% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/3) | 1.4% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/3) | n/p |
Side Air Bag | driver -side knee air bag | no | no | no |
Side Crash Protect | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Skid Plates | no | no | no | yes |
Spare Tire Type | fullsize | fullsize | compact | fullsize |
Stability Bars (Front/Rear) (inches) | n/p | 0.91 / n/p | n/p | 0.9 / n/p |
Theft Deterrent System | yes | no | no | no |
Theft Frequency | n/p | average | average | average |
Tires | 205 / 75 R 15 | 215 / 70 R 16 | 215 / 75 R 15 | 235 / 75 R 15 |
Tires Quality Rating / Rank | n/p | 3.1% worse than average / tied for 12th (w/5) | 16.3% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/3) | 3.1% worse than average / tied for 12th (w/5) |
Traction (Front / Rear) | 56.7 / 56.7 | 57.5 / 57.7 | 58 / 58 | 59.6 / 59.8 |
Traction Control | n/p | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Wheelbase (inches) | 92.9 | 86.6 | 101.4 | 106.4 |
Width (inches) | 68.1 | 66.6 | 69.4 | 70.4 |
IV. COMFORT | ||||
Air Cleaning | no | no | no | no |
Air Conditioning | no | no | no | no |
AM / FM Radio | no | no | yes | yes |
Arm Rests | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Automatic Climate Control | no | no | no | no |
Automatic Headlights | no | no | no | no |
Automatic Parking Brake Release | n/p | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Automatic Seat Belts | no | no | no | no |
Availability of Parts - Rating / Rank | 81.1% worse than avg / 18th | 43.5% worse than avg / tied for 12th | 0.8% better than avg / tied for 9th | 74.9% worse than avg / 16th |
Bucket Seats | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Built In Cupholders | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Cargo Tie Down Hooks | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Cassette Player | no | no | no | yes |
CD Player | no | no | no | yes |
Chime Headlights On Warning | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Chrome Grill | no | no | no | yes |
Console Operation - Rating / Rank | 4.7% better than average / tied for 6th (w/7) | 27.8% worse than avg / tied for 20th (w/2) | 1.8% worse than average / 16th | yes |
Contour - Rating / Rank | 12.1% better than average / tied for 4th (w/2) | 12.1% better than average / tied for 4th (w/2) | 25.2% worse than average / tied for 20th (w/2) | yes |
Cruise Control | no | no | no | yes |
Dealership Experience - Rating / Rank | 13% worse than avg / tied for 11th (w/2) | 37% worse than avg / tied for 20th | 17% worse than avg / tied for 14th | yes |
Decor - Rating / Rank | 29.6% worse than average / 20th | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | yes |
Digital Clock | yes | yes | no | yes |
Driver Side Express Window | yes | no | no | yes |
Driving Range - Rating / Rank | 16.1% shorter than average / 19th | 2.5% longer than average / 7th | 16.3% longer than average / 3rd | yes |
Driving Range (miles) | 331.8 | 405.5 | 460 | yes |
Dual Temperature Air Conditioning | no | no | no | yes |
Ease of Getting In & Out - Rating / Rank | 16.6% better than average / tied for 4th | 10.3% worse than average / tied for 12th (w3) | 28.3% worse than average / tied for 20th (w/2) | yes |
Engine Heater | no | no | no | yes |
Environmental Concerns - Rating / Rank | 5% better than average / 7th | 32.5% better than average / 1st | 15% better than average / tied for 3rd | yes |
Ergonomics - Rating / Rank | 7.1% worse than average / 15th | 17.1% worse than average / 17th | 21.4% worse than average / 18th | yes |
Fuel Capacity (gallons) | 15.8 | 15.3 | 20 | yes |
Glass Tint | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Head Rests | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Heated Seats | no | no | no | yes |
Heated Side Mirror | no | no | no | yes |
Illuminated Entry System | no | no | no | yes |
Illuminated Vanity Mirrors | no | no | no | yes |
Instrument Panel Layout & Quality - Rating / Rank | 0.3% better than average / tied for 10th | 3.1% worse than average / tied for 12th (w/2) | 17% worse than average / tied for 17th | yes |
Interior & Exterior Noise - Rating / Rank | 10.9% noisier than avg / tied for 13th (w / 2) | 53.1% noisier than average / tied for 20th | 25% noisier than average / 18th | yes |
Keyless Entry | no | no | no | yes |
Leather Seats / Upholstery | no | no | no | yes |
Leather Wrapped Steering Wheel | no | no | no | yes |
Luggage Rack | no | no | no | yes |
Sunroof / Moonroof | no | no | no | yes |
Map Lights | no | no | no | yes |
Map Pockets | yes | no | no | yes |
Memory System for Seats, Mirrors, Radio, etc. | no | no | no | yes |
Number Of Dealerships | 400 | 1,194 | 2,130 | yes |
Number Of Dealerships Rating / Rank | 81.1% less than average / 18th | 43.5% less than average / tied for 12th | 0.8% more than average / tied for 9th | yes |
Percent of All Dealerships | 1.7% | 5.2% | 9.3% | yes |
Power Accessory Outlet(s) | yes | yes | no | yes |
Power Adjustable Pedals with Memory | no | no | no | yes |
Power Antenna | no | no | no | yes |
Power Door Locks | yes | no | no | yes |
Power Lumbar Support | no | no | no | yes |
Power Mirrors | yes | no | yes | yes |
Power Seats | no | no | no | yes |
Power Steering | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Steering Cooler | no | no | no | yes |
Power Trunk / Hood / Gas Cap | yes | no | no | yes |
Power Windows | yes | no | no | yes |
Rear Audio Controls & Headphone Jacks | no | no | no | yes |
Rear Defogger | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Rear Seat Ventilation | no | no | no | yes |
Rear Wiper / Washer | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Ride Quality - Rating / Rank | 16.4% worse than average / tied for 17th | 11.4% worse than average / tied for 14th | 24.7% worse than average / 19th | yes |
Running Boards | no | no | no | yes |
Sliding Rear Window | no | no | no | yes |
Sound System Quality - Rating / Rank | n/p | 11% worse than average / 15th | 18.7% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/4) | yes |
Spare Tire Cover | yes | no | no | yes |
Telephone | no | no | no | yes |
Tilt / Telescopic Steering | yes | yes | no | yes |
Trunk Cargo Organizer | no | no | no | yes |
Turning Cycle - Curb to Curb | 34.8 | 33.5 | 35.9 | yes |
Turning Cycle - Rating / Rank | 6.7% better than avg / tied for 3rd (w/3) | 10.2% better than average / 1st | 3.8% better than average / 8th | yes |
Two-tone Paint | no | no | no | yes |
Universal Garage Door Opener | no | no | no | yes |
Variable Assist Steering | no | no | no | yes |
Wheels | steel | steel | steel | yes |
White Design Tires | no | no | no | yes |
Wood Interior Trim | no | no | no | yes |
V. ROOMINESS | ||||
Cargo Volume - Rating / Rank | 49.1% smaller than average / 19th | 55.2% smaller than average / 20th | 10.8% smaller than average / 15th | 48.1% smaller than average / 7th |
Cargo Volume (cubic feet) | 39.4 | 34.7 | 69 | 81.1 |
Driver / Passenger Room - Rate / Rank | 8.1% worse than average / 14th | 15.2% worse than average / tied for 18th | 34% worse than average / 20th | 0.4% better than average / 12th |
Head Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 39.6 / 37.8 | 40 / 39.1 | 37.8 / 38 | 38.9 / 38.3 |
Hip Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 52.5 / 50.4 | 55.8 / 39.6 | 54.8 / 44.3 | 52.2 / 52.2 |
Leg Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 44.5 / 31.1 | 39.5 / 33.9 | 41.5 / 35 | 42.1 / 35 |
Passenger Number (Seating) | 5 | 4 | 5 | 5 |
Passenger Number Rating / Rank | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 24.5% less than average / tied for 20th | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) |
Rear Folding Seats | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Shoulder Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 54.4 / 54.4 | 53.3 / 50.2 | 54.7 / 54.7 | 56.3 / 56.3 |
Storage Compartments - Rating / Rank | n/p | 23.6% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/7) | 15% worse than average / tied for 15 (w/2) | 23.6% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/7) |
VI. EXPERTS' CONSENSUS (****) | ||||
Average of Overall Rating / Rank | 7% advantage to list price / #1 | 4.6% disadvantage to list price / 13th | 5% disadvantage to list price / tied for 14th | 4.5% disadvantage / 12th |
VII. POPULARITY | ||||
Customer Satisfaction - Rating / Rank | 80% worse than average / 20th | 60% better than average / tied for 1st | 20% worse than average / tied for 15th (w/2) | average / tied for 6th (w/8) |
Fashionableness - Rating / Rank | 13% less than average / tied for 14th | 13% less than average / tied for 14th | 27.5% less than average / tied for 20th | 23.2% more than average / 2nd |
1997 / 1998 Sales | not made / 28,582 | 67,489 / 64,990 | 130,041 / 146,298 | 63,627 / 59,889 |
1998 Sales - Rating / Rank | 74.8% less than average / 20th | 43.3% less than average / 12th | 27.5% more tjhan average / 6th | 47.8% less than average / 13th |
Popularity Rank in its Price Range | 3rd | 2nd | 1st | 4th |
Sales Trend - Rating / Rank | first year in production | 3.7% decline / 15th | 12.5% rise / 8th | 5.9% decline / 17th |
Status Symbol - Rating / Rank | 54.5% lower than average / 20th | 39.4% lower than average / tied for 18th | 39.4% lower than average / tied for 18th | 24.2% lower than avg / tied for 13th (w/4) |
VIII. ECONOMY | ||||
Basic Warranty | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 50,000 miles |
Basic Warranty - Rating / Rank | 5% less than average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% less than average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% less than average / tied for 5th (w/15) | |
Fuel Economy City / Highway mpg | 19 / 23 (avg 21) | 24 / 29 (avg 26.5) | 21 / 25 (avg 23) | 21 / 24 (avg 22.5) |
Fuel Economy - Rating / Rank | 5% better than average / 7th | 32.5% better than average / 1st | 15% better than average / tied for 3rd | 12.5% better than average / 5th |
True Fuel Economy (per weight) - Rating / Rank | 18.5% worse than average / 20th | 11.1% worse than average / tied for 18th | 3.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) | 18.5% better than average / tied for 1st |
Included Equipment - Rating / Rank | 94.2% less than average / 18th | 288.4%less than average / 20th | 72.7% less than average / 16th | 51% less than average / 15th |
Overall Warranty - Rating / Rank | 0.5% worse than average / 12th | 13.9% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 14.1% worse than avg / tied for 17th (W/2) | 7.1% better than average / 6th |
Per Mile Cost of Operation - Rating / Rank | 51.9% better than average / tied for 3rd | 1.3% better than average / tied for 10th (w/2) | 24.1% worse than average / tied for 13th (w/2) | 24.1% worse than average / tied for 13th (w/2) |
Powertrain Warranty | 60 months / 60,000 miles | 60 months / 60,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 60 months / 60,000 miles |
Resale Value - Rating / Rank | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 65.1% better than average / tied for 1st | 45% worse than average / tied for 19th | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) |
Roadside Assistance - Rating / Rank | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) | 34.8% worse than average / tied for 3rd (w/5) |
Rust Warranty | 60 months / 100,000 miles | 60 months / unlimited mileage | 60 months / 100,000 miles | 72 months / 100,000 miles |
Group 1 | Kia Sportage 2wd 2dr conv. | Toyota RAV4 Soft Top 2wd 2dr | Jeep Cherokee S 2wd 2dr | Isuzu Rodeo S 2wd 4dr |
Please scroll down to view:
Group 2 | Mitsubishi Montero Sport ES 2wd 4dr | Chevrolet Blazer 2wd 2dr | Honda CRV LX 2wd (front) 4dr | GMC Jimmy 2wd 2dr |
Group 3 | Ford Explorer Sport 2wd 2dr | Toyota 4-Runner 2wd 4dr | Chevrolet Tahoe 2wd 2dr | Nissan Pathfinder XE 2wd 4dr |
Group 4 | Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 2wd 4dr | Dodge Durango 2wd SLT 5.2 V8 4dr | Mercury Mountaineer 2wd 4dr | Ford Expedition 2wd XLT 4dr |
Group 5 | Oldsmobile Bravada | Lexus RX-300 2wd (front) 4dr | Mercedes ML320 | Lincoln Navigator 2wd 4dr |
Carvalu.com™ SCROLL DOWN COMPARISON CHART WITH ROUNDED DOLLAR FIGURES (*) Copyright 1988-2010 Tommy Vig --Group Two of Five |
||||
Mitsubishi Montero Sport ES 2wd 4dr | Chevrolet Blazer 2wd 2dr | Honda CRV LX 2wd (front) 4dr | GMC Jimmy 2wd 2dr | |
Retail Price (MSRP) | $18,300 | $18,500 | $18,500 | $18,500 |
Wholesale Price (Invoice) | $17,000 | $16,700 | $16,950 | $16,770 |
Destination Charge | $460 | $530 | $420 | $530 |
Dealer Hold Back (Approximate) | $370 | $550 | $370 | $560 |
Value Per Professionals' Consensus (**) (+ / -) | $16,390=[-$1910] | $18,320=[-$180] | $18,970=+$470 | $17,330=[-$1170] |
"Honest" Base Price ™ (***) - Rating / Rank | $16,940 (7.5% disadv -$1,360) / 11th (w/2) | $17,640 (4.5% disadv -$860) / tied for 7th | $17,160 (7.5% disadv -$1,340) / 11th (w/2) | $17,610 (5% disadvantage -$890) / 9th |
YOUR VALUE™ ~ see interactive WIP pie | ||||
TRUE VALUE™ ~ see interactive WIP pie | ||||
I. PERFORMANCE | ||||
0-60 mph acceleration (seconds) | 12.3 | 8.7 | 10.6 | 8.7 |
Acceleration - Rating / Rank | 23.5% slower than average / 19th | 12.7% quicker than average / tied for 3rd | 6.4% slower than average / 15th | 12.7% quicker than average / teid for 3rd |
All Wheel Drive | no | no | no | no |
"Attitude" | More Truck-like | More Truck-like | More Truck-like | More Truck-like |
Cylinders | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 |
Cylinders- Rating / Rank | 29.8% less than average / tied for 14th (w/6) | 5.3% more than average / tied for 5th (w/8) | 29.8% less than average / tied for 14th (w/6) | 5.3% more than average / tied for 5th (w/8) |
Displacement in Cubic Inches (ci) | 143 | 262 | 120 | 262 |
Displacement - Rating / Rank | 33.9% smaller than average / 16th | 21% larger than average / tied for 5th (w/2) | 44.6% smaller than average / 20th | 21% larger than average / tied for 5th (w/2) |
Engine Location / Drive Wheels | front / rear | front / rear | front / rear | front / rear |
Engine Type | 2.4L I4 | 4.3L V6 | 2.0L I4 | 4.3L V6 |
EPA Classification | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD |
4-Wheel Drive | no | no | no | no |
Fuel Delivery System | MPFI | SEFI | MPFI | SEFI |
Ground Clearance (inches) | 7.7 | 8.1 | 8.1 | 8.1 |
Handling and Driveability - Rating / Rank | 19.7% below average / tied for 18th | 9.2% better than average / 6th | 20.5% better than average / 2nd | 1.2% better than average / tied for 8th (w/2) |
Horsepower | 132 | 190 | 146 | 190 |
Horsepower - Rating / Rank | 28.7% less than average / 16th | 2.6 more than average / tied for 9th (w/2) | 21.2% less than average / 15th | 2.6 more than average / tied for 9th (w/2) |
Maximum Allowable Weight | 4,731 lbs. | 4,450 lbs. | 4,166 lbs. | 4,450 lbs. |
Maximum Allowable Weight Rating / Rank | 6.4% less than average / 11th | 12% less than average / tied for 14th | 17.6% less than average / 17th | 12% less than average / tied for 14th |
Off Road Ability - Rating / Rank | 5.1% better than average / tied for 9th (w/2) | 13.3% below average / 12th | 47.5% below average / tied for 20th (w/2) | 40.1% better than average / tied for 3rd |
Overall Performance - Rating / Rank | 41.2% worse than avg / tied for 15th (w/5) | 41.2% worse than avg / tied for 15th (w/5) | 17.6% worst than average / tied for 5th (w/4) | 41.2% worse than avg / tied for 15th (w/5) |
Payload (lbs.) | 1230 | 950 | 1500 | 932 |
Payload Rating / Rank | 2.7% less than average / 9th | 24.9% less than average / 16th | 18.6% better than average / 7th | 26.3% less than averrage / 17th |
Reviewers' Recommendation - Rating / Rank | 23% less than avg / tied for 16th | 20% less than avg / tied for 12th (w/3) | 12% more than avg / tied for 7th | 20% less than avg / tied for 12th ( w/3) |
Standard Transmission | 5 speed manual | 5 speed manual | 4 speed automatic | 5 speed manual |
Steering | recirc | recirc. | rack & pinion | recirc. |
Stroke | 100 | 88.4 | 89 | 88.4 |
Suspension (Front / Rear) | independent / live | independent / live | independent / independent | independent / live |
Top Speed | 107 mph | 115 mph | 96 mph | 115 mph |
Top Speed-Rating / Rank | 0.4% faster than average / 11th | 4.9% faster than average / tied for 7th (w/2) | 12.4% slower than average / 18th | 4.9% faster than average / tied for 7th (w/2) |
Torque | 148 @ 2,750 | 250 @ 2,800 | 133 @ 4,500 | 250 @ 2800 |
Tow Capacity / Hauling (lbs.) | 1,500 | 4,000 | 1,000 | 4,500 |
Tow Capacity / Hauling-Rating / Rank | 57.7% less than average / tied for 18th | 12.7% more than average / 9th | 70.8% less than average / 20th | 26.8% more than average / 8th |
Trailering Equipment | no | yes | no | yes |
Transmission Quality - Rating / Rank | 13.7% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/6) | 13.7% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/6) | 0.7% better than average / tied for 9th (w/3) | 0.7% better than average / tied for 9th (w/3) |
Valves | 16 | 12 | 16 | 12 |
Valves - Rating / Rank | 3.2% better than average / teid for 4th (w/8) | 22.6% less than average / tied for 13th (w/6) | 3.2% better than average / tied for 4th (w/8) | 22.6% less than average / tied for 4th (w/6) |
Weight Distribution Front / Rear | 52 / 48 | 54 / 46 | 56 / 44 | 54 / 46 |
II. RELIABILITY | ||||
Battery - Rating / Rank | 582 | 525 | 405 | 525 |
Battery Amps | 6.1% more than average / tied for 9th (w/2) | 4.3% less than average / tied for 12th (w/3) | 26.2% less than average / 18th | 4.3% less than average / tied for 12th (w/3) |
Cold Climate Package | no | no | no | no |
Frequency of Repair - Rating / Rank | 23.6% worse than average / tied for 17th | 16.7% worse than average / 15th | 4.2% better than average / tied for 11th | 9.7% worse than average / 14th |
General - Rating / Rankng | 6% worse than avg / tied for 15th (w/4) | 6% worse than avg / tied for 15th ( w/4) | 11% better than avg / tied for 3rd | 6% worse than avg / tied for 15th (w/4) |
Number of Complaints - Rating / Rank | 64.4% less (better) than avg / 6th | 68.5% less (better) than avg / 5th | 100% less (better) than avg / tied for 1st | 43.8% less (better) than avg / 9th |
Model Year of Production | 8th | 5th | 3rd | 5th |
Recalls - Rank | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) | tied for 1st (no recalls) |
Reputation of Manufacturer - Rating / Rank | 20% worse than average / tied for 18th | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 9.4% better than average / 5th | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) |
III. SAFETY | ||||
60 mph-0 Braking Distance (feet) | 143 | 146 | 138 | 146 |
60 mph-0 Braking Distance - Rating / Rank | 5.1% shorter (better) than average / 6th | 3.1% shorter ( better) than avg. / tied for 8th | 8.4% shorter (better) than avg. / tied for 3rd | 3.1% shorter (better) than avg. / tied for 8th |
Anti-lock Brake System (ABS) | no | yes | no | yes |
Auto Leveling Suspension System | n/p (not published) | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Brakes (Front / Rear) | disc / drum | disc / disc | disc / drum | disc / disc |
Brake Quality - Rating / Rank | 4.8% worse than average / 14th | 14.3% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/2) | 4.8% better than average / 8th | 14.3% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/3) |
Bumper Strength | poor | poor | n/p | poor |
Cargo Net | no | no | no | no |
Curb Weight (lbs.) | 3,510 | 3,531 | 3,126 | 3,536 |
Curb Weight Rank | 14th | 13th | 17th | 12th |
Day / Night Rear View Mirror | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Daylight Running Lights | no | yes | no | yes |
Driver Air Bag | yes | yes | yes | |
Dual Note Horn | no | yes | no | yes |
First Aid Kit | no | no | no | no |
Fog Lights | no | no | no | no |
Front, Back, & Side Visibility - Rating / Rank | 15.4% better than average / tied for 1st (w/5) | 27.9% worse than average / 19th | 8.1% better than average / tied for 8th | 71% worse than average / 20th |
Global Position / Navigation System (GPS) | no | no | no | no |
Halogen Headlights | no | no | yes | no |
Height (inches) | 67.5 | 64.9 | 65.9 | 64.7 |
Insurance Company Rating / Rank | 84.4% worse than avg / tied for 20th (w/2) | 21.9% worse than avg / tied for 9th (w/8) | 56.3% better than average / tied for 1st (w/8) | 84.4% worse than avg / tied for 20th (w/2) |
Length (inches) | 178.3 | 176.8 | 177.6 | 176.8 |
Maneuverability - Rating / Rank | 25.9% worse than average / 17th | 9.2% better than average / tied for 4th (w/7) | 1.4% better than average / tied for 12th | 9.2% better than average / tied for 4th (w/7) |
NHTSA, etc. Frontal Crash Test Results-R/R | 30.1% worse than average / tied for 20th | 0.9% better than average / tied for 10th (w/2) | 24.2% better than average / tied for 2nd | 0.9% better than average / tied for 10th (w/2) |
Occupant Injury Statistics Rating | n/p | 12.1% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/4) | 12.1% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/4) | 12.1% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/4) |
Overall Size - Rating / Rank | 2.5% smaller than average / 16th | 2.8% smaller than average / 17th | 2% smaller than average / 14th | 2.4% smaller than average / 15th |
Passenger Air Bag | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Brakes | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Reverse Sensing System | no | no | no | no |
Road Holding Index | 0.67 | 0.72 | 0.75 | 0.70 |
Road Holding Index - Rating / Rank | 5.6% worse than average / 18th | 1.4% better than avg./ tied for 6th | 5.6% better than avg. / 3rd | 1.4% worse than avg. / tied for 13th (w/3) |
Side Air Bag | no | no | no | no |
Side Crash Protect | no | yes | no | yes |
Skid Plates | yes | no | no | no |
Spare Tire Type | fullsize | fullsize | fullsize | fullsize |
Stability Bars (Front/Rear) (inches) | 1.22 / 1.02 | 1.30 / 0.91 | 1.30 / 0.91 | |
Theft Deterrent System | no | yes | no | yes |
Theft Frequency | very high | average | n/p | average |
Tires | 225 / 75 R 15 | 235 / 70 R 15 | 205 / 70 R 15 | 235 / 70 R 15 |
Tires Quality Rating / Rank | n/p | 6.6% better than average / tied for 6th | 3.1% worse than average / tied for 12th (w/5) | 6.6% better than average / tied for 6th |
Traction (Front / Rear) | 155.9 / 56.5 | 55 / 54.6 | 60.4 / 60.4 | 55 / 54.6 |
Traction Control | n/p | no | n/p | no |
Wheelbase (inches) | 107.3 | 100.5 | 103.2 | 100.5 |
Width (inches) | 66.7 | 67.8 | 68.9 | 67.8 |
IV. COMFORT | ||||
Air Cleaning | no | no | yes | no |
Air Conditioning | no | yes | yes | yes |
AM / FM Radio | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Arm Rests | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Automatic Climate Control | no | no | no | no |
Automatic Headlights | no | yes | no | yes |
Automatic Parking Brake Release | n/p | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Automatic Seat Belts | no | no | no | no |
Availability of Parts - Rating / Rank | 76.2% worse than avg / 17th | 103.5% better than avg / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 54.8% worse than avg / 15th | 103.5% better than avg / tied for 3rd (w/2) |
Bucket Seats | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Built In Cupholders | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Cargo Tie Down Hooks | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Cassette Player | no | yes | yes | yes |
CD Player | yes | no | no | no |
Chime Headlights On Warning | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Chrome Grill | no | yes | no | yes |
Console Operation - Rating / Rank | 27.8% worse than avg / tied for 20th (w/2) | 12.6% better than average / 2nd | 4.7% better than average / tied for 6th (w/7) | 8.3% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/2) |
Contour - Rating / Rank | 25.2% worse than avg / tied for 20th (w/2) | 6.5% better than average / tied for 7th (w/10) | 6.5% better than average / tied for 7th (w/10) | 12.1% better than average / tied for 4th (w/2) |
Cruise Control | no | no | yes | no |
Dealership Experience - Rating / Rank | 34% worse than avg / 18th | 22% better than avg / 6th | 22% worse than avg / 16th | 23% better than avg / tied for 3rd (w/2) |
Decor - Rating / Rank | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 15.5% worse than average / tied for 18th | 15.5% worse than average / tied for 18th |
Digital Clock | no | yes | yes | yes |
Driver Side Express Window | no | no | yes | no |
Driving Range - Rating / Rank | 13.4% longer than average / 5th | 3.9% shorter than average / tied for 9th | 7.2% shorter than average / 16th | 3.9% shorter than average / tied for 9th |
Driving Range (miles) | 448.5 | 380 | 367.2 | 380 |
Dual Temperature Air Conditioning | no | yes | yes | yes |
Ease of Getting In & Out - Rating / Rank | 28.3% worse than average / tied for 20th | 10.3% worse than avg / tied for 12th (w/3) | 7.6% better than average / tied for 6th (w/4) | 28.3% worse than average / tied for 20th |
Engine Heater | no | no | no | no |
Environmental Concerns - Rating / Rank | 15% better than average / tied for 3rd | average / tied for 10 (w/2) | 20% better than average / 2nd | average / tied for 10th (w/2) |
Ergonomics - Rating / Rank | 28.5% worse than average / 20th | 5.6% worse than average / 14th | 9.9% worse than average / 16th | 11.5% better than average / tied for 3rd |
Fuel Capacity (gallons) | 19.5 | 19 | 15.3 | 19 |
Glass Tint | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Head Rests | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Heated Seats | no | no | no | no |
Heated Side Mirror | no | no | no | no |
Illuminated Entry System | no | no | no | no |
Illuminated Vanity Mirrors | no | no | no | no |
Instrument Panel Layout & Quality - Rating / Rank | 30.8% worse than average / 20th | 3.1% worse than average / tied for 12th (w2) | 3.8% better than average / tied for 7th (w/2) | 24.6% better than average / tied for 1st |
Interior & Exterior Noise - Rating / Rank | 53.1% noisier than average / tied for 20th | 1.5% noisier than average / 11th | 10.9% noisier than avg / tied for 13th (w/2) | 15.6% noiser than average / 17th |
Keyless Entry | no | yes | no | no |
Leather Seats / Upholstery | no | no | no | no |
Leather Wrapped Steering Wheel | no | no | no | no |
Luggage Rack | no | yes | no | yes |
Sunroof / Moonroof | no | no | no | no |
Map Lights | yes | no | yes | no |
Map Pockets | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Memory System for Seats, Mirrors, Radio, etc. | no | no | no | no |
Number Of Dealerships | 502 | 4,300 | 956 | 4,300 |
Number Of Dealerships Rating / Rank | 76.2% less than average / 17th | 103.5% more than avg / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 54.8% less than average / 15th | 103.5% more than avg / tied for 3rd (w/2) |
Percent of All Dealerships | 2.2% | 18.7% | 4.2% | 18.7% |
Power Accessory Outlet(s) | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Adjustable Pedals with Memory | no | no | no | no |
Power Antenna | no | no | no | no |
Power Door Locks | no | no | yes | no |
Power Lumbar Support | no | no | no | no |
Power Mirrors | no | yes | yes | yes |
Power Seats | no | no | no | no |
Power Steering | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Steering Cooler | no | no | no | no |
Power Trunk / Hood / Gas Cap | no | no | yes | no |
Power Windows | no | no | yes | no |
Rear Audio Controls & Headphone Jacks | no | no | no | no |
Rear Defogger | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Rear Seat Ventilation | no | no | yes | no |
Rear Wiper / Washer | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Ride Quality - Rating / Rank | 37.3% worse than average / 20th | 0.3% better than average / tied for 9th (w/2) | 4.7% worse than average / tied for 12 | 12% better than average / 7th |
Running Boards | no | no | no | no |
Sliding Rear Window | no | no | no | no |
Sound System Quality - Rating / Rank | 18.7% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/4) | 25.8% worse than avg / tied for 16th (w/3) | 40.7% worse than average / 20th | 25.8% worse than avg / tied for 16th (w/3) |
Spare Tire Cover | no | no | yes | no |
Telephone | no | no | no | no |
Tilt / Telescopic Steering | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Trunk Cargo Organizer | no | no | no | no |
Turning Cycle - Curb to Curb | 40.7 | 34.8 | 34.8 | 34.8 |
Turning Cycle - Rating / Rank | 9.1% worse than average / 19th | 6.7% better than avg / tied for 3rd (w/3) | 6.7% better than avg / tied for 3rd (w/3) | 6.7% better than avg / tied for 3rd (w/3) |
Two-tone Paint | no | no | no | no |
Universal Garage Door Opener | no | no | no | no |
Variable Assist Steering | no | yes | no | yes |
Wheels | steel | alloy | steel | alloy |
White Design Tires | no | no | no | no |
Wood Interior Trim | no | no | no | no |
V. ROOMINESS | ||||
Cargo Volume - Rating / Rank | 2.1% bigger than average / 10th | 13.5% smaller than average / 17th | 13.2% smaller than average / 16th | 13.5% smaller than average / 17th |
Cargo Volume (cubic feet) | 79 | 66.9 | 67.2 | 66.9 |
Driver / Passenger Room - Rate / Rank | 15.2% worse than average / tied for 18th | 14.7% worse than average / tied for 16th | 9.8% worse than average / 15th | 14.7% worse than average / tied for 16th |
Head Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 38.9 / 37.3 | 39.6 / 38.3 | 40.5 / 39.2 | 39.6 / 38.3 |
Hip Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 53.1 / 50.8 | 52 / 40.5 | 53.4 / 50.7 | 52 / 40.4 |
Leg Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 42.8 / 33.5 | 42.4 / 35.6 | 41.5 / 36.7 | 42.4 / 35.6 |
Passenger Number (Seating) | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 |
Passenger Number Rating / Rank | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) |
Rear Folding Seats | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Shoulder Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 55.5 / 55.5 | 57.7 / 55.6 | 53.4 / 50.7 | 57.7 / 55.6 |
Storage Compartments-Rating/Rank | n/p | 15% worse than average / tied for 15 (w/2) | 23.6% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/7) | 15% worse than average / tied for 15 (w/2) |
VI. EXPERTS' CONSENSUS (****) | ||||
Average of Overall Rating / Rank | 10.4% disadvantage to list price / 20th | 1% disadvantage to list price / 7th | 2.5% advantage to list price / 3rd | 6.3% disadvantage to list price / 16th |
VII. POPULARITY | ||||
Customer Satisfaction - Rating / Rank | 20% better than average / 5th | 20% worse than average / tied for 15th (w/2) | average / tied for 6th (w/8) | 20% worse than average / tied for 15th (w/2) |
Fashionableness - Rating / Rank | 8.7% more than average / tied for 6th (w/3) | 8.7% more than average / tied for 6th (w/3) | 13% less than average / tied for 14th (w/3) | 8.7% more than average / tied for 6th (w/3) |
1997 / 1998 Sales | 31,659 / 38,439 | 219,710 / 219,710 | 128,496 / 100,582 | 75,817 / 72,301 |
1998 Sales - Rating / Rank | 66.5% less than average / 17th | 91.5% more than average / 4th | 12.3% less than average / 9th | 37% less than average / 10th |
Popularity Rank in its Price Range | 5th | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
Sales Trend - Rating / Rank | 21.4% rise / 7th | 0.8% decline / 14th | 50.7% rise / 6th | 4.6% decline / 18th |
Status Symbol - Rating / Rank | 24.2% lower than avg / tied for 13th (w/4) | 24.2% lower than avg / tied for 13th (w/4) | 24.2% lower than avg / tied for 13th (w/4) | 24.2% lower than avg / tied for 13th (w/4) |
VIII. ECONOMY | ||||
Basic Warranty | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles |
Basic Warranty - Rating / Rank | 5% less than average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% less than average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% less than average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% less than average / tied for 5th (w/15) |
Fuel Economy City / Highway mpg | 22 / 24 (avg 23) | 17 / 23 (avg 20) | 23 / 25 (avg 24) | 17 / 23 (avg 20) |
Fuel Economy - Rating / Rank | 15% better than average / tied for 3rd | average / tied for 10th (w/2) | 20% better than average / 2nd | average / tied for 10th (w/2) |
True Fuel Economy (per weight) - Rating / Rank | 18.5% better than average / tied for 1st | 3.7% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/7) | 3.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) | 3.7% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/7) |
Included Equipment - Rating / Rank | 7.9% less than average / tied for 11th (w/2) | 35.3% more than average / tied for 7th | 7.9% less than average / tied for 11th (w/2) | 28.1% more than average / 9th |
Overall Warranty - Rating / Rank | 6.3% better than average / 7th | 10.7% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/3) | 0.3% better than average / tied for 8th (w/3) | 10.7% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/3) |
Per Mile Cost of Operation - Rating / Rank | 49.4% worse than average / tied for 16th | 26.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/4) | 49.4% worse than average / tied for 16th | 26.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/4) |
Powertrain Warranty | 60 months / 60,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles |
Resale Value - Rating / Rank | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 26.6% worse than average / 18th | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 45% worse than average / tied for 19th |
Roadside Assistance - Rating / Rank | 34.8% worse than average / tied for 3rd (w/5) | 34.8% worse than average / tied for 3rd (w/5) | 34.8% worse than average / tied for 3rd (w/5) | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) |
Rust Warranty | 84 months / 100,000 miles | 72 months / 100,000 miles | 60 months / unlimited mileage | 72 months / 100,000 miles |
Group 1 | Kia Sportage 2wd 2dr conv. | Toyota RAV4 Soft Top 2wd 2dr | Jeep Cherokee S 2wd 2dr | Isuzu Rodeo S 2wd 4dr |
Group 2 | Mitsubishi Montero Sport ES 2wd 4dr | Chevrolet Blazer 2wd 2dr | Honda CRV LX 2wd (front) 4dr | GMC Jimmy 2wd 2dr |
Please scroll down to view:
Group 3 | Ford Explorer Sport 2wd 2dr | Toyota 4-Runner 2wd 4dr | Chevrolet Tahoe 2wd 2dr | Nissan Pathfinder XE 2wd 4dr |
Group 4 | Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 2wd 4dr | Dodge Durango 2wd SLT 5.2 V8 4dr | Mercury Mountaineer 2wd 4dr | Ford Expedition 2wd XLT 4dr |
Group 5 | Oldsmobile Bravada | Lexus RX-300 2wd (front) 4dr | Mercedes ML320 | Lincoln Navigator 2wd 4dr |
Carvalu.com™ SCROLL DOWN COMPARISON CHART WITH ROUNDED DOLLAR FIGURES (*) Copyright 1988-2010 Tommy Vig --Group Three of Five |
||||
Ford Explorer Sport 2wd 2dr | Toyota 4-Runner 2wd 4dr | Chevrolet Tahoe 2wd 2dr | Nissan Pathfinder XE 2wd 4dr | |
Retail Price (MSRP) | $20,000 | $21,000 | $24,000 | $24,100 |
Wholesale Price (Invoice) | $18,270 | $18,360 | $21,000 | $21,950 |
Destination Charge | $520 | $420 | $640 | $520 |
Dealer Hold Back (Approximate) | $600 | $370 | $720 | $770 |
Value Per Professionals' Consensus (**) (+ / -) | $21,290=+$1290 | $20,460=[-$540] | 23,700=[-$300] | $21, 960=[-$2140] |
"Honest" Base Price ™ (***) - Rating / Rank | $20,870 (4% advantage +$870) / tied for 2nd | $16,680 (20.5% disadvantage -$4,320) / 19th | $24,980 (4% advantage +$980) / tied for 2nd | $21,010 (13% disadvantage -$3,090) / 18th |
YOUR VALUE™ ~ see interactive WIP pie | ||||
TRUE VALUE™ ~ see interactive WIP pie | ||||
I. PERFORMANCE | ||||
0-60 mph aAcceleration (seconds) | 8.8 | 12.2 | 7.8 | 9.8 |
Acceleration - Rating / Rank | 12% quicker than average / 5th | 22.5% slower than average / 18th | 21.7% quicker than average / 1st | 1.6% quicker than average / 11th |
All Wheel Drive | no | no | no | no |
"Attitude" | More Truck-like | More Truck-like | More Truck-like | More Truck-like |
Cylinders | 6 | 4 | 8 | 6 |
Cylinders- Rating / Rank | 5.3% more than average / tied for 5th (w/8) | 29.8% less than average / tied for 14th (w/6) | 40.4% more than average / tied for 1st (w/3) | 5.3% more than average / tied for 5th (w/8) |
Displacement in Cubic Inches (ci) | 245 | 164 | 350 | 200 |
Displacement - Rating / Rank | 13.2% larger than average / tied for 8th | 24.2% smaller than average / 14th | 61.7% larger than average / 1st | 7.6% smaller than average / 11th |
Engine Location / Drive Wheels | front / rear | front / rear | front / rear | front / rear |
Engine Type | 4.0 L V6 | 2.7 L I4 | 5.7L V8 | 3.3L V6 |
EPA Classification | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD |
4-Wheel Drive | no | no | no | no |
Fuel Delivery System | SEFI | SEFI | SEFI | SEFI |
Ground Clearance (inches) | 6.7 | 9.8 | 7.2 | 7.5 |
Handling and Driveability - Rating / Rank | 5% below average / tied for 12th (w/2) | 24.5% below average / 20th | 0.4% below average / 11th | 15.7% better than average / tied for 3rd |
Horsepower | 160 | 150 | 255 | 168 |
Horsepower - Rating / Rank | 13.6% less than average / 13th | 19% less than average / 14th | 37.7% more than average / 2nd | 9.3% less than average / 12th |
Maximum Allowable Weight | 4,425 lbs. | 5,250 lbs. | 6,100 lbs. | 3,700 lbs. |
Maximum Allowable Weight Rating / Rank | 12.5% less than average / 16th | 3.8% more than average / 8th | 20.6% more than average / 3rd | 26.8% less than average / 19th |
Off Road Ability - Rating / Rank | 38.7% below average / tied for 16th | 57.6% better than average / tied for 1st | 21.2% below average / 14th | 47.5% below average / tied for 20th (w/2) |
Overall Performance - Rating / Rank | 37.3% better than average / tied for 3rd | 17.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/4) | 41.2% worse than avg / tied for 15th (w/5) | 21.6% worse than average / tied for 13th |
Payload (lbs.) | 750 | 1810 | 1590 | 900 |
Payload Rating / Rank | 40.7% less than average / 20th | 43.2% more than averrage / 1st | 25.8% more than average / 6th | 28.8% less than average / 18th |
Reviewers' Recommendation - Rating / Rank | 28% more than avg / tied for 3rd | 12% more than avg / tied for 6th w/2 | 26% less than avg / 18th | 9% more than avg / 9th |
Standard Transmission | 5 speed manual | 4 speed automatic | 4 speed automatic | 5 speed manual |
Steering | rack & pinion | rack & pinion | recirc | rack & pinion |
Stroke | 84.3 | 95 | 88.4 | 83 |
Suspension (Front / Rear) | independent / live | independent / live | independent / live | independent / live |
Top Speed | 106 mph | 105 mph | 117 mph | 103 mph |
Top Speed-Rating / Rank | 3.3% slower than average / 14th | 4.2% slower than avg / 15th | 6.8% faster than average / tied for 4th (w/2) | 6% slower than average / 16th |
Torque | 225 @ 2,750 | 117 @ 4,000 | 330 @ 2,800 | 196 @ 2,800 |
Tow Capacity / Hauling (lbs.) | 2,000 | 3,500 | 5,000 | 3,500 |
Tow Capacity / Hauling-Rating / Rank | 43.7% less than average / tied for 14th (w/3) | 1.4% less than average / tied for 10th (w/2) | 40.8% more than average / tied for 4th (w/2) | 1.4% less than average / tied for 10th (w/2) |
Trailering Equipment | no | no | yes | no |
Transmission Quality - Rating / Rank | 15.1% better than average / tied for 1st (w/7) | 15.1% better than average / tied for 1st (w/7) | 15.1% better than average / tied for 1st (w/7) | 13.7% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/6) |
Valves | 12 | 16 | 16 | 12 |
Valves - Rating / Rank | 22.6% less than average/ tied for 13th (w/6) | 3.2% more than average / tied for 4th (w/8) | 3.2% more than average / tied for 4th (w/2) | 22.6% less than average / tied for 13th (w/6) |
Weight Distribution Front / Rear | 52 / 48 | 53 / 47 | 53 / 47 | 53 / 47 |
II. RELIABILITY | ||||
Battery - Rating / Rank | 18.5% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/3) | 6.1% better than average / tied for 9th (w/2) | 9.4% better than average / tied for 6th (w/2) | 4.3% less than average / tied for 12th (w/3) |
Battery Amps | 650 | 582 | 600 | 525 |
Cold Climate Package | no | no | no | no |
Frequency of Repair - Rating / Rank | 4.2% better than average / tied for 11th | 25% better than average / 2nd | 5.6% better than average / tied for 9th | 11.1% better than average / tied for 4th (w/3) |
General Rating / Rank | 8% better than avg / tied for 5th | 8% better than avg / tied for 5th | 6% worse than avg / tied for 15th w/4 | 2% better than avg / tied for 7th |
Number of Complaints - Rating / Rank | 42.5% less (better) than avg / 10th | 76.7% less (better) than avg / 9th | 95.9% more (worse) than avg / 17th | 79.5% less (better) than avg / 3rd |
Model Year of Production | 5th | 4th | n/p (not published) | 4th |
Recalls - Rank | 14th | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) |
Reputation of Manufacturer - Rating / Rank | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 25% better than average / tied for 3rd | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) |
III. SAFETY | ||||
60 mph-0 Braking Distance (feet) | 180 | 150 | 148 | 154 |
60 mph-0 Braking Distance - Rating / Rank | 19.4% below average / 19th | 0.5% better than average / 13th | 1.8% better than average / 11th | 2.2% worse than average / 14th |
Anti-lock Brake System (ABS) | yes | no | yes | yes |
Auto Leveling Suspension System | no | no | no | no |
Brakes (Front / Rear) | disc / disc | disc / drum | disc / drum | disc / disc |
Brake Quality - Rating / Rank | 13% better than average / tied for 4th | 1% worse than average / 12th | 18.1% worse than average / tied for 16th | 2.9% better than average / 9th |
Bumper Strength | poor | poor | n/p | n/p |
Cargo Net | no | no | no | yes |
Curb Weight (lbs.) | 3,675 | 3,440 | 4,525 | 3,700 |
Curb Weight Rank | 11th | 16th | 3rd | 9th |
Day / Night Rear View Mirror | yes | no | yes | no |
Daylight Running Lights | no | no | yes | no |
Driver Air Bag | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Dual Note Horn | yes | no | no | no |
First Aid Kit | no | no | no | no |
Fog Lights | no | no | no | no |
Front, Back, & Side Visibility - Rating / Rank | 6% below average / 17th | 15.4% better than average / tied for 1st (w/5) | 15.4% better than average / tied for 1st (w/5) | 11% better than average / 7th |
Global Position / Navigation System (GPS) | no | no | no | no |
Halogen Headlights | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Height (inches) | 67.1 | 67.5 | 71.4 | 67.1 |
Insurance Company Rating / Rank | 56.3% better than average/tied for 1st (w/7) | 84.4% worse than avg / tied for 20th (w/2) | 56.3% better than averrage / tied for 1st (w/6) | 21.9% worse than average / tied for 9th (w/8) |
Length (inches) | 180.8 | 183.2 | 188 | 178.3 |
Maneuverability - Rating / Rank | 1.4% better than average / tied for 12th | 45.4% worse than average / 20th | 6.4% worse than average / tied for 14th | 24.9% better than average / tied for 2nd |
NHTSA, etc. Frontal Crash Test Results-R/R | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) | 24.2% better than average / tied for 2nd | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) | 22.4% worse than avg / tied for 16th (w/2) |
Occupant Injury Statistics Rating | 23% better than average / tied for 4th | 29.7% worse than average / 18th | 58.2% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/2) | 12.1% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/4) |
Overall Size - Rating / Rank | 0.2% smaller than average / 8th | 0.5% smaller than average / 10th | 5.4% bigger than average / 3rd | 1.4% smaller than average / 12th |
Passenger Air Bag | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Brakes | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Reverse Sensing System | no | no | no | no |
Road Holding Index | 0.72 | n/p | 0.76 | 0.68 |
Road Holding Index - Rating / Rank | 1.4% better than average / 6th | n/p | 7% better than average / 2nd | 4.2% worse than average / 17th |
Side Air Bag | no | no | no | no |
Side Crash Protect | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Skid Plates | no | no | no | no |
Spare Tire Type | fullsize | fullsize | fullsize | fullsize |
Stability Bars (Front/Rear) (inches) | 1.34 / 0.77 | 1.02 / 0.75 | 1.25 / n/p | 1.06 / 0.59 |
Theft Deterrent System | yes | no | yes | yes |
Theft Frequency | average | high | average | very high |
Tires | 235 / 75 R 15 | 225 / 75 R 15 | 235 / 75 R 15 | 235 / 70 R 15 |
Tires Quality Rating / Rank | 3.1% below the average / tied for 12th (w/5) | 16.3% better than average / (w/3) | n/p | 41.9% worse than average / 20th |
Traction (Front / Rear) | 58.5 / 58.5 | 59.3 / 58.9 | 63.6 / 63.6 | 58.3 / 58.5 |
Traction Control | no | no | no | no |
Wheelbase (inches) | 101.7 | 105.3 | 111.5 | 106.3 |
Width (inches) | 70.2 | 66.5 | 77.1 | 68.7 |
IV. COMFORT | ||||
Air Cleaning | no | no | no | no |
Air Conditioning | yes | no | no | yes |
AM / FM Radio | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Arm Rests | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Automatic Climate Control | no | no | no | no |
Automatic Headlights | no | yes | no | no |
Automatic Parking Brake Release | n/p | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Automatic Seat Belts | no | no | no | no |
Availability of Parts - Rating / Rank | 111.9% better than the avg / tied for 1st | 43.5% better than average / tied for 12th | 103.5% better than avg / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 47.9% worse than avg / 14th |
Bucket Seats | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Built In Cupholders | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Cargo Tie Down Hooks | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Cassette Player | yes | no | no | yes |
CD Player | no | no | no | yes |
Chime Headlights On Warning | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Chrome Grill | no | yes | no | no |
Console Operation - Rating / Rank | 8.3% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 4.7% better than average / tied for 6th (w/7) | 8.3% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 4% better than average / tied for 14th |
Contour - Rating / Rank | 6.5% below average / tied for 7th (w/10) | 6.5% below average / tied for 7th (w/10) | 6.5% below average / tied for 7th (w/10) | 25.2% worse than avg / tied for 20th (w/2) |
Cruise Control | no | no | no | no |
Dealership Experience- Rating / Rank | 16% better than average / tied for 9th | 37% worse than average / tied for 20th | 22% better than average / tied for 6th | 30% worse than average / 17th |
Decor - Rating / Rank | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 12.7% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/3) | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) |
Digital Clock | yes | no | no | yes |
Driver Side Express Window | yes | no | no | no |
Driving Range - Rating / Rank | 9.3% shorter the average / 18th | 4.1% shorter than average / tied for 12th | 21.3% longer than average / 1st | 4% shorter than average / 11th |
Driving Range (miles) | 358.8 | 379.3 | 480 | 379.8 |
Dual Temperature Air Conditioning | yes | no | no | yes |
Ease of Getting In & Out - Rating / Rank | 7.6 % better than average / tied for 6th (w/4) | 7.6 % better than average / tied for 6th (w/4) | 16.6% better than average / tied for 4th | 10.3% worse than avg / tied for 12th (w/3) |
Engine Heater | no | no | no | no |
Environmental Concerns - Rating / Rank | 2.5 % better than average / tied for 8th | 2.5 % better than average / tied for 8th | 20% worse than average / 18th | 10% worse than average / tied for 15th |
Ergonomics - Rating / Rank | 2.9 % better than average / 12th | 2.8% worse than average / 13th | 11.5% better than average / 3rd | 8.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/2) |
Fuel Capacity (gallons) | 17.5 | 18.5 | 30 | 21 |
Glass Tint | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Head Rests | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Heated Seats | no | no | no | no |
Heated Side Mirror | no | no | no | no |
Illuminated Entry System | yes | no | yes | no |
Illuminated Vanity Mirrors | yes | no | no | no |
Instrument Panel Layout & Quality - Rating / Rank | 10.7% better than average / tied for 4th | 17% worse than average / tied for 17th | 24.6% better than average / tied for 1st | 6.6% worse than average / tied for 15th |
Interior & Exterior Noise - Rating / Rank | 10.9% noisier than avg. / tied for 13th (w/2) | 11.8% noisier than average / 16th | 40.7% quieter than average / 1st | 0.6% noiser than average / 10th |
Keyless Entry | yes | no | no | no |
Leather Seats / Upholstery | no | no | no | no |
Leather Wrapped Steering Wheel | yes | no | no | no |
Luggage Rack | yes | |||
Map Lights | yes | no | yes | yes |
Map Pockets | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Memory System for Seats, Mirrors, Radio, etc. | no | no | no | no |
Number Of Dealerships | 4,477 | 1,194 | 4,300 | 1,100 |
Number Of Dealerships Rating / Rank | 111.9% more than average / tied for 1st | 43.5% less than average / tied for 12th | 103.5% more than avg / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 47.9% less than average / 14th |
Percent of All Dealerships | 19.5% | 5.2% | 18.7% | 4.8% |
Power Accessory Outlet(s) | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Adjustable Pedals with Memory | no | no | no | no |
Power Antenna | no | no | no | no |
Power Door Locks | yes | no | yes | yes |
Power Lumbar Support | no | no | no | no |
Power Mirrors | yes | no | yes | yes |
Power Seats | no | no | no | no |
Power Steering | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Steering Cooler | no | no | no | no |
Power Trunk / Hood / Gas Cap | yes | yes | no | yes |
Power Windows | yes | no | no | yes |
Rear Audio Controls & Headphone Jacks | no | no | no | no |
Rear Defogger | yes | yes | no | yes |
Rear Seat Ventilation | no | no | yes | no |
Rear Wiper / Washer | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Ride Quality - Rating / Rank | 11.4 % below average / tied for 14th | 3.2% better than average / 8th | 14.3% worse than average / 16th | 0.3% better than average / tied for 9th (w/2) |
Running Boards | no | no | no | no |
Sliding Rear Window | no | yes | no | no |
Sound System Quality - Rating / Rank | 23.5% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/4) | 25.8% worse than avg / tied for 16th (w/3) | n/p | 33.5% better than average / 1st |
Spare Tire Cover | no | no | no | no |
Sunroof / Moonroof | no | no | no | no |
Telephone | no | no | no | no |
Tilt / Telescopic Steering | yes | no | yes | yes |
Trunk Cargo Organizer | no | no | no | no |
Turning Cycle - Curb to Curb | 34.7 | 38.1 | 38.1 | 35.4 |
Turning Cycle - Rating / Rank | 7% better than average / 2nd | 2.1% worse than average / tied for 12th | 2.1% worse than average / tied for 12th | 5.1% better than average / 7th |
Two-tone Paint | no | no | no | no |
Universal Garage Door Opener | no | no | no | no |
Variable Assist Steering | no | no | yes | no |
Wheels | alloy | steel | steel | chrome |
White Design Tires | no | no | no | no |
Wood Interior Trim | no | no | no | no |
V. ROOMINESS | ||||
Cargo Volume - Rating / Rank | 7.6 % bigger than average / tied for 4th (w/3) | 3.1% bigger than average / 9th | 28.4% bigger than average / 3rd | 9.9% bigger than average / 6th |
Cargo Volume (cubic feet) | 69.4 | 79.8 | 99.4 | 85 |
Driver/Passenger Room-Rate/Rank | 3.2 % bigger than avg / 8th | 1.4% bigger than average / tied for 9th | 15.5% bigger than average / 3rd | 1% worse than average / 12th |
Head Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 39.3 / 39.3 | 39.3 / 38.7 | 39.9 / 37.8 | 39.5 / 37.5 |
Hip Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 51.4 / 43.6 | 49.8 / 51.3 | 60 / 60.7 | 54.1 / 51.5 |
Leg Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 42.4 / 34.5 | 42.6 / 35 | 41.9 / 36.4 | 41.7 / 31.8 |
Passenger Number (Seating) | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5 |
Passenger Number Rating / Rank | 24.5% less than average / tied for 20th | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) |
Rear Folding Seats | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Shoulder Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 56.7 / 58 | 53.6 / 53.3 | 65.4 / 66 | 56.6 / 56.4 |
Storage Compartments-Rating/Rank | 69.1% less than the average/20th | 23.6% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/7) | n/p | 7.3% worse than average / 14th |
VI. EXPERTS' CONSENSUS (****) | ||||
Average of Overall Rating / Rank | 6.5% adv. to list price / 2nd | 2.6% disadv. to list price / 11th | 1.3% disadv. to list price / tied for 9th | 8.9% disadv. to list price / 18th |
VII. POPULARITY | ||||
Customer Satisfaction - Rating / Rank | 40% better than average / tied for 3rd | 60% better than average / tied for 1st | average / tied for 6th (w/8) | 40% better than average / tied for 3rd |
Fashionableness - Rating / Rank | 1.4% more than avg / tied for 10th (w/2) | 13% less than average / tied for 14th (w/3) | 27.5% less than average / tied for 20th | 1.4% more than avg / tied for 10th (w/2) |
1997 / 1998 Sales | 338,852 / 431488 | 128,496 / 118,484 | 133,235 / 133,235 | 73,365 / 68,003 |
1998 Sales - Rating / Rank | 276.2% more than the average / 1st | 3.3% more than average / 8th | 16.1% more than average / 7th | 40.7% less than average / 11th |
Popularity Rank in its Price Range | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th |
Sales Trend - Rating / Rank | 12.4% rise / 9th | 7.8% decline / 19th | 7.3% rise / 10th | 7.3% decline / 18th |
Status Symbol - Rating / Rank | 9.1% lower than average / tied for 11th | 9.1% lower than average / tied for 11th | 6.1% higher than avg / tied for 7th (w/3) | 6.1% higher than avg / tied for 7th (w/3) |
VIII. ECONOMY | ||||
Basic Warranty | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles |
Basic Warranty - Rating / Rank | 5% below the average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% below the average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% below the average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% below the average / tied for 5th (w/15) |
Fuel Economy City / Highway mpg | 18 / 23 (avg 20.5) | 18 / 25 (avg 21.5) | 14 / 18 (avg 16) | 17 / 19 (avg 18) |
Fuel Economy - Rating / Rank | 2.5 % better than average / tied for 8th | 2.5 % better than average / tied for 8th | 20% worse than average / 18th | 10% worse than average / tied for 15th |
True Fuel Economy (per weight) - Rating / Rank | 3.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) | 3.7% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/7) | 3.7% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/7) | 11.1% worse than average / tied for 18th |
Included Equipment - Rating / Rank | 158% more than average / 2nd | 195% less than average / 19th | 157.6% more than average / 3rd | 87.1% less than average / 17th |
Overall Warranty - Rating / Rank | 0.3% better than average / tied for 8th (w/3) | 13.9% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 10.7% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/3) | 13.9% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/2) |
Per Mile Cost of Operation - Rating / Rank | 77.2% better than average / tied for 1st | 1.3% better than average / tied for 10th (w/2) | 26.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/4) | 1.3% better than average / tied for 10th (w/2) |
Powertrain Warranty | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 60 months / 60,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 60 months / 60,000 miles |
Resale Value - Rating / Rank | 28.4% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 65.1% better than average / tied for 1st | 28.4% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 28.4% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/2) |
Roadside Assistance - Rating / Rank | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) | 34.8% worse than average / tied for 3rd (w/5) | 34.8% worse than average / tied for 3rd (w/5) |
Rust Warranty | 60 months / unlimited mileage | 60 months / unlimited mileage | 72 months / 100,000 miles | 60 months / unlimited mileage |
Group 1 | Kia Sportage 2wd 2dr conv. | Toyota RAV4 Soft Top 2wd 2dr | Jeep Cherokee S 2wd 2dr | Isuzu Rodeo S 2wd 4dr |
Group 2 | Mitsubishi Montero Sport ES 2wd 4dr | Chevrolet Blazer 2wd 2dr | Honda CRV LX 2wd (front) 4dr | GMC Jimmy 2wd 2dr |
Group 3 | Ford Explorer Sport 2wd 2dr | Toyota 4-Runner 2wd 4dr | Chevrolet Tahoe 2wd 2dr | Nissan Pathfinder XE 2wd 4dr |
Please scroll down to view:
Group 4 | Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 2wd 4dr | Dodge Durango 2wd SLT 5.2 V8 4dr | Mercury Mountaineer 2wd 4dr | Ford Expedition 2wd XLT 4dr |
Group 5 | Oldsmobile Bravada | Lexus RX-300 2wd (front) 4dr | Mercedes ML320 | Lincoln Navigator 2wd 4dr |
Carvalu.com™ SCROLL DOWN COMPARISON CHART WITH ROUNDED DOLLAR FIGURES (*) Copyright 1988-2010 Tommy Vig --Group Four of Five |
||||
Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 2wd 4dr | Dodge Durango 2wd SLT 5.2 V8 4dr | Mercury Mountaineer 2wd 4dr | Ford Expedition 2wd XLT 4dr | |
Retail Price (MSRP) | $26,000 | $26,000 | $27,100 | $29,400 |
Wholesale Price (Invoice) | $23,500 | $23,530 | $24,540 | $26,700 |
Destination Charge | $525 | $525 | $525 | $640 |
Dealer Hold Back (Approximate) | $780 | $780 | $810 | $880 |
Value Per Professionals' Consensus (**) (+ / -) | $25,750=[-$250] | $26,200=+$200 | $24,950 = [-$2,150] | $29,050 = [-$350] |
"Honest" Base Price ™ (***) - Rating / Rank | $23,960 (7.5% disadv -$2,040) / 11th (w/2) | $25,870 (0.5% disadvantage -%130) / 5th | $26,350 (3% disadvantage -$750) / 6th | $29,415 (0.05% advantage +$15) / 4th |
YOUR VALUE™ ~ see interactive WIP pie | ||||
TRUE VALUE™ ~ see interactive WIP pie | ||||
I. PERFORMANCE | ||||
0-60 Acceleration (seconds) | 9.2 | 9.0 | 8.5 | 10.5 |
Acceleration - Rating / Rank | 7.6% quicker than average / 9th | 9.6% quicker than average / tied for 6th | 14.7% quicker than average / 2nd | 5.4% slower than average / 14th |
All Wheel Drive | no | no | no | no |
"Attitude" | More Truck-like | More Truck-like | More Truck-like | More Truck-like |
Cylinders | 6 | 8 | 6 | 8 |
Cylinders- Rating / Rank | 5.3% more than average / tied for 5th (w/8) | 40.4% more than average / tied for 1st (w/3) | 5.3% more than average / tied for 5th (w/8) | 40.4% more than average / tied for 1st (w/3) |
Displacement in Cubic Inches (ci) | 242 | 318 | 245 | 281 |
Displacement - Rating / Rank | 11.8% larger than average / 10th | 46.9% larger than average / 3rd | 13.2% larger than average / tied for 8th | 29.8% larger than average / 4th |
Engine Location / Drive Wheels | front / rear | front / rear | front / rear | front / rear |
Engine Type | 4.0L I6 | 5.2L V8 | 4.0L V6 | 4.6L V8 |
EPA Classification | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD | SPURP2WD |
4-Wheel Drive | no | no | no | no |
Fuel Delivery System | SEFI | SEFI | SEFI | SEFI |
Ground Clearance (inches) | 8.9 | 7.9 | 6.7 | 7.5 |
Handling and Driveability - Rating / Rank | 10.8% better than average / 5th | 19.7% below average / tied for 18th | 5.2% below average / tied for 12th (w/3) | 6.6% better than average / 7th |
Horsepower | 195 | 230 | 210 | 240 |
Horsepower - Rating / Rank | 5.3% more than average / 8th | 24.2% more than average / 4th | 13.4% more than average / 7th | 29.6% more than average / 3rd |
Maximum Allowable Weight | 5,150 lbs. | 6,050 lbs. | 5580 lbs. | 7,000 lbs. |
Maximum Allowable Weight Rating / Rank | 1.9% more than average / 9th | 19.7% more than average / 4th | 10.4% more than average / 6th | 38.4% more than average / 1st |
Off Road Ability - Rating / Rank | 57.6% better than average / tied for 1st | 22.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/3) | 29.9% below average / 15th | 5.1% better than average / tied for 9th (w/2) |
Overall Performance - Rating / Rank | 17.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/4) | 41.2% worse than avg / tied for 15th (w/5) | 17.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/4) | 2% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/2) |
Payload (lbs.) | 1150 | 1656 | 1100 | 1800 |
Payload Rating / Rank | 9% less than average / 12th | 30% more than average / 5th | 13% less than average / 13th | 42.4% more than average / tied for 2nd |
Reviewers' Recommendation - Rating / Rank | 7% more than avg / 10th | 36% less than avg / 20th | 20% more than avg / 5th | 12% more than avg / tied for 6th (w/2) |
Standard Transmission | 4 speed automatic | 4 speed automatic | 5 speed automatic | 4 speed automatic |
Steering | recirc. | rack & pinion | rack & pinion | recirc. |
Stroke | 86.7 | 84.1 | 84.3 | 90 |
Suspension (Front / Rear) | live / live | independent / live | independent / live | independent / independent |
Top Speed | 118mph | 120mph | 109mph | 117mph |
Top Speed-Rating / Rank | 7.7% faster than average / 3rd | 9.5% faster than average / tied for 1st | 0.5% slower than average / tied for 12th | 6.8% faster than average / tied for 4th (w/2) |
Torque | 230 @ 3,000 | 300 @ 3,200 | 250 @ 3,000 | 345 @ 2,300 |
Tow Capacity / Hauling (lbs.) | 2,000 | 4,700 | 5,300 | 5,900 |
Tow Capacity / Hauling-Rating / Rank | 43.7% less than average / tied for 14th (w/3) | 32.4% more than average / 7th | 49.3% more than average / 3rd | 66.2% more than average / 2nd |
Trailering Equipment | no | no | no | yes |
Transmission Quality - Rating / Rank | 13.7% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/6) | 0.7% better than average / tied for 9th (w/3) | 15.1% better than average / tied for 1st (w/7) | 15.1% better than average / tied for 1st (w/7) |
Valves | 12 | 16 | 12 | 16 |
Valves - Rating / Rank | 22.6% less than average / tied for 13th (w/6) | 3.2% more than the avg / tied for 4th (w/8) | 22.6% less than average / tied for 13th (w/6) | 3.2% more than the avg / tied for 4th (w/8) |
Weight Distribution Front / Rear | 56 / 44 | 54 / 46 | n/p (not published) | 54 / 46 |
II. RELIABILITY | ||||
Battery - Rating / Rank | 13.9% more than the avg / 5th | 9.4% more than the avg / tied for 6th (w/2) | 18.5% more than the avg / tied for 1st (w/3) | 18.5% more than the avg / tied for 1st (w/3) |
Battery Amps | 625 | 600 | 650 | 650 |
Cold Climate Package | no | no | no | no |
Frequency of Repair - Rating / Rank | 8.3% better than average / 8th | 18.1% better than average / 3rd | 5.6 % better than average / tied for 9th | 11.1 % better than average / tied for 4th (w/3) |
General - Rating / Rank | 4% worse than avg / tied for 10th (w/2) | 4% worse than avg / tied for 10th (w/2) | Average / 9th | 11% better than avg / tied for 3rd |
Number of Complaints - Rating / Rank | 109.6% more (worse) than avg / 18th | 57.5% more (worse) than avg / 14th | 100% less (better) than avg / tied for 1st | 57.5% less (better) than avg / tied for 7th |
Model Year of Production | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 3rd |
Recalls - Rank | 13th | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) | 19th | 15th |
Reputation of Manufacturer - Rating / Rank | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) |
III. SAFETY | ||||
60 mph-0 Braking Distance (feet) | 131 | 165 | 187 | 157 |
60 mph-0 Braking Distance - Rating / Rank | 13.1% beter than average / 2nd | 9.5% worse than average / 18th | 24.1% worse than average / 20th | 4.2% worse than average / 15th |
Anti-lock Brake System (ABS) | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Auto Leveling Suspension System | no | no | no | no |
Brakes (Front / Rear) | disc / disc | disc / drum | disc / disc | disc / disc |
Brake Quality - Rating / Rank | 42.9% better than average / 1st | 10.5% worse than average / 15th | 2.9% worse than average / 13th | 18.1% worse than average / 16th |
Bumper Strength | n/p | n/p | poor | n/p |
Cargo Net | no | no | no | no |
Curb Weight (lbs.) | 3,740 | 4,260 | 4,140 | 4,805 |
Curb Weight Rank | 8th | 5th | 6th | 2nd |
Day / Night Rear View Mirror | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Daylight Running Lights | no | no | no | no |
Driver Air Bag | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Dual Note Horn | no | yes | no | no |
First Aid Kit | no | no | no | no |
Fog Lights | yes | no | yes | no |
Front, Back, & Side Visibility - Rating / Rank | .9% better than average / tied for 10th (w/6) | .9% better than average / tied for 10th (w/6) | 15.4% better than average / tied for 1st (w/5) | 15.4% better than average / tied for 1st (w/5) |
Global Position / Navigation System (GPS) | no | no | no | no |
Halogen Headlights | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Height (inches) | 69.4 | 71 | 70.5 | 74.3 |
Insurance Company Rating / Rank | 56.3% better than avg / tied for 10th (w/7) | 56.3% better than avg / tied for 10th (w/7) | 21.9% worse than average / tied for 9th (w/8) | 56.3% better than avg / tied for 10th (w/7) |
Length (inches) | 181.5 | 193.3 | 190.1 | 204.6 |
Maneuverability - Rating / Rank | 7.9% worse than average / 16th | 9.2% better than average / tied for 4th (w/7) | 24.9% better than average / tied for 2nd | 9.2% better than average / tied for 4th (w/7) |
NHTSA, etc. Frontal Crash Test Results-R/R | n/p | 30.1% worse than average / tied for 20th | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) |
Occupant Injury Statistics Rating | n/p | n/p | 23% better than average / tied for 4th | 58.2% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/2) |
Overall Size - Rating / Rank | 1.4% larger than average / 6th | 5.5% larger than average / 4th | 2.9% larger than average / 5th | 12.2% larger than average / 2nd |
Passenger Air Bag | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Brakes | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Reverse Sensing System | no | no | no | no |
Road Holding Index | 0.78 | 0.71 | 0.67 | 0.70 |
Road Holding Index - Rating / Rank | 9.9% better than average / 1st | average / tied for 8th | 5.6% worse than average / tied for 18th | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 13th (w/3) |
Side Air Bag | no | no | no | no |
Side Crash Protect | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Skid Plates | no | no | no | no |
Spare Tire Type | compact | fullsize | fullsize | fullsize |
Stability Bars (Front/Rear) (inches) | n/p | n/p | 1.34 / 0.77 | 1.34 / 0.83 |
Theft Deterrent System | yes | no | yes | yes |
Theft Frequency | very high | n/p | average | average |
Tires | 225 / 75 R 16 | 235 / 75 R 15 | 225 / 70 R 15 | 255 / 70 R 16 |
Tires Quality Rating / Rank | 35.7% better than average / 1st | n/p | 3.1% worse than average / tied for 12th (w/5) | 16.3% better than average / tied for 2nd (w3) |
Traction (Front / Rear) | 59.5 / 59.5 | 60.5 / 61.9 | 58.5 / 58.5 | 65.4 / 65.5 |
Traction Control | no | no | no | no |
Wheelbase (inches) | 105.9 | 115.9 | 111.6 | 119.1 |
Width (inches) | 72.3 | 71.5 | 70.2 | 78.6 |
IV. COMFORT | ||||
Air Cleaning | no | no | no | no |
Air Conditioning | yes | yes | yes | yes |
AM / FM Radio | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Arm Rests | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Automatic Climate Control | no | no | no | no |
Automatic Headlights | no | no | no | no |
Automatic Parking Brake Release | n/p | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Automatic Seat Belts | no | no | no | no |
Availability of Parts - Rating / Rank | 0.8% better than avg / tied for 9th | 37.8% better than avg / 6th | 18.8% better than avg / 8th | 111.9% better than avg / tied for 1st |
Bucket Seats | yes | yes | no | no |
Built In Cupholders | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Cargo Tie Down Hooks | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Cassette Player | yes | yes | yes | yes |
CD Player | no | no | no | no |
Chime Headlights On Warning | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Chrome Grill | no | no | no | no |
Console Operation - Rating / Rank | 4.7% better than average / tied for 6th (w/7) | 4.7% better than average / tied for 6th (w/7) | 4.7% better than average / tied for 6th (w/7) | 4% better than average / tied for 14th |
Contour - Rating / Rank | 30.8% better than average / tied for 2nd | 6.5% below average / tied for 7th (w/10) | 6.5% below average / tied for 7th (w/10) | 6.5% below average / tied for 7th (w/10) |
Cruise Control | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Dealership Experience - Rating / Rank | 17% worse than average / tied for 14th | 13% worse than average / tied for 11th | 18% better than average / 8th | 16% better than average / tied for 9th |
Decor - Rating / Rank | 12.7% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/3) | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) |
Digital Clock | no | no | yes | no |
Driver Side Express Window | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Driving Range - Rating / Rank | 4.1% shorter than average / tied for 12th | 4.3% longer than average / 6th | 7.1% shorter than average / 15th | 1.9% longer than average / 8th |
Driving Range (miles) | 379.3 | 412.5 | 367.5 | 403 |
Dual Temperature Air Conditioning | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Ease of Getting In & Out - Rating / Rank | 25.6% better than average / tied for 2nd | 7.6% better than average / tied for 6th (w/4) | 19.3% worse than average / tied for 16th | 10.3% worse than avg / tied for 12th (w/3) |
Engine Heater | no | no | no | no |
Environmental Concerns - Rating / Rank | 7.5% worse than average / 14th | average / tied for 10th (w/2) | 12.5% worse than average / 17th | 22.5% worse than average / 19th |
Ergonomics - Rating / Rank | 7.2% better than average / tied for 9th (w2) | 21.4% worse than average / tied for 18th | 8.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/3) | 8.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/3) |
Fuel Capacity (gallons) | 20.5 | 25 | 21 | 26 |
Glass Tint | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Head Rests | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Heated Seats | no | no | no | no |
Heated Side Mirror | no | no | no | no |
Illuminated Entry System | yes | no | yes | no |
Illuminated Vanity Mirrors | no | no | yes | no |
Instrument Panel Layout & Quality - Rating / Rank | 20.4% worse than average / 19th | 3.1% worse than average / tied for 12th (w/2) | 10.7% better than average / tied for 4th | 0.3% better than average / tied for 10th |
Interior & Exterior Noise - Rating / Rank | 7.9% quieter than average / tied for 7th | 6.2% noisier than average / 12th | 12.5% quieter than average / 6th | 19.7% quieter than average / 5th |
Keyless Entry | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Leather Seats / Upholstery | no | no | no | no |
Leather Wrapped Steering Wheel | no | no | yes | no |
Luggage Rack | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Map Lights | no | no | yes | yes |
Map Pockets | yes | yes | yes | no |
Memory System for Seats, Mirrors, Radio, etc. | no | no | no | yes |
Number Of Dealerships | 2,130 | 2,912 | 2,511 | 4,477 |
Number Of Dealerships Rating / Rank | 0.8% more than average / tied for 9th | 37.8% more than average / 6th | 18.8% more than average / 8th | 111.9% more than average / tied for 1st |
Percent of All Dealerships | 19.8% | 12.7% | 10.9% | 19.5% |
Power Accessory Outlet(s) | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Adjustable Pedals with Memory | no | no | no | no |
Power Antenna | no | no | no | no |
Power Door Locks | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Lumbar Support | no | no | no | no |
Power Mirrors | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Seats | no | no | no | yes |
Power Steering | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Steering Cooler | no | no | no | no |
Power Trunk / Hood / Gas Cap | no | no | no | no |
Power Windows | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Rear Audio Controls & Headphone Jacks | no | no | no | no |
Rear Defogger | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Rear Seat Ventilation | no | no | no | no |
Rear Wiper / Washer | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Ride Quality - Rating / Rank | 17.1% better than average / 4th | 0.3% better than average / tied for 9th (w/2) | 16.4% worse than average / tied for 17th | 35.5% better than average / 1st |
Running Boards | no | no | yes | no |
Sliding Rear Window | no | no | no | no |
Sound System Quality - Rating / Rank | 3.9% better than average / tied for 8th (w/3) | n/p | 18.7% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/4) | 3.9% better than average / tied for 8th (w/3) |
Spare Tire Cover | no | no | no | no |
Sunroof / Moonroof | no | no | no | no |
Telephone | no | no | no | no |
Tilt / Telescopic Steering | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Trunk Cargo Organizer | no | yes | no | no |
Turning Cycle - Curb to Curb | 36.5 | 38.9 | 37.3 | 40.4 |
Turning Cycle - Rating / Rank | 2.1% better than average / 9th | 4.3% worse than average / 15th | average / 11th | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 17th |
Two-tone Paint | no | no | yes | no |
Universal Garage Door Opener | no | no | no | no |
Variable Assist Steering | no | yes | no | yes |
Wheels | alloy | alloy | aluminum | alloy |
White Design Tires | yes | yes | no | no |
Wood Interior Trim | no | no | no | no |
V. ROOMINESS | ||||
Cargo Volume - Rating / Rank | 6.6% smaller than average / 13th | 13.7% bigger than average / 4th | 3.7% bigger than average / 8th | 52.9% bigger than average / 1st |
Cargo Volume (cubic feet) | 72.3 | 88 | 80.2 | 118.3 |
Driver/Passenger Room-Rate/Rank | 2.7% worse than average / 13th | 2.5% bigger than average / 8th | 4.3% bigger than average / tied for 5th | 36.7% bigger than average / 2nd |
Head Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 39.7 / 39.5 | 39.8 / 40.4 | 39.3 / 39.3 | 39.8 / 39.8 |
Hip Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 56.5 / 52.4 | 56.7 / 56 | 52.3 / 51.6 | 61.5 / 62.3 |
Leg Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 41.4 / 35.3 | 41.9 / 37.3 | 42.4 / 35.8 | 40.9 / 38.9 |
Passenger Number (Seating) | 5 | 7 | 5 | 9 |
Passenger Number Rating / Rank | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 32.1% more than average / tied for 2nd | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 69.8% more than average / 1st |
Rear Folding Seats | yes | yes | yes | no |
Shoulder Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 58.9 / 57.8 | 57.3 / 57.5 | 56.2 / 56.6 | 63.9 / 64.4 |
Storage Compartments-Rating/Rank | 53.6% worse than average / 19th | n/p | 23.6% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/7) | 23.6% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/7) |
VI. EXPERTS' CONSENSUS (****) | ||||
Average of Overall Rating / Rank | 1% disadv. to list price / tied for 7th | 0.8% advantage to list price / 4th | 7.9% disadvantage to list price / 17th | 1.2% disadv. to list price / tied for 9th |
VII. POPULARITY | ||||
Customer Satisfaction - Rating / Rank | average / tied for 6th (w/8) | average / tied for 6th (w/8) | average / tied for 6th (w/8) | 40% worse than average / tied for 18th |
Fashionableness - Rating / Rank | 30.4% more than average / 1st | 15.9% more than avg / tied for 3rd (w/2) | 1.4% more than avg / tied for 10th (w/2) | 15.9% more than avg / tied for 3rd (w/2) |
1997 / 1998 Sales | 260,875 / 229,135 | 20,263 / 156,923 | 45,363 / 47,595 | 214,524 / 225,703 |
1998 Sales - Rating / Rank | 99.8% more than average / 2nd | 36.8% more than average / 5th | 58.5% less than average / 14th | 96.8% more than average / 3rd |
Popularity Rank in its Price Range | 1st | 2nd | 5th | 1st |
Sales Trend - Rating / Rank | 12.2% decline / 20th | 674.4% rise / 1st | 4.9% rise / 13th | 5.2% rise / 12th |
Status Symbol - Rating / Rank | 6.1% higher than avg / tied for 7th (w/3) | 6.1% higher than avg / tied for 7th (w/3) | 21.2% higher than average / 6th | 36.4% higher than average / tied for 4th |
VIII. ECONOMY | ||||
Basic Warranty | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles |
Basic Warranty - Rating / Rank | 5% below the average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% below the average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% below the average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 5% below the average / tied for 5th (w/15) |
Fuel Economy City / Highway mpg | 16 / 21 (avg 18.5) | 14 / 19 (avg 16.5) | 15 / 20 (avg 17.5) | 13 / 18 (avg 15.5) |
Fuel Economy - Rating / Rank | 7.5% worse than average / 14th | average / tied for 10th (w/2) | 12.5% worse than average / 17th | 22.5% worse than average / 19th |
True Fuel Economy (per weight) - Rating / Rank | 3.7% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/7) | 3.7% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/7) | 3.7% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/7) | 3.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) |
Included Equipment - Rating / Rank | 7.9% less than average / tied for 11th (w/2) | 92.8% more than the average / 5th | 56.8% more than average / 6th | 100.7% more than average / 4th |
Overall Warranty - Rating / Rank | 14.1% worse than avg / tied for 17th (w/2) | 14.1% worse than avg / tied for 17th (w/2) | 0.3% better than average / tied for 8th (w/3) | 0.3% better than average / tied for 8th (w/3) |
Per Mile Cost of Operation - Rating / Rank | 51.9% better than average / tied for 3rd | 24.1% worse than average / tied for 13th (w/2) | 77.2% better than average / tied for 1st | 74.7% worse than average / tied for 18th (w/2) |
Powertrain Warranty | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 36 months / 36,000 miles |
Resale Value - Rating / Rank | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) |
Roadside Assistance - Rating / Rank | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) |
Rust Warranty | 60 months / 100,000 miles | 60 months / 100,000 miles | 60 months / unlimited mileage | 60 months / unlimited mileage |
Group 1 | Kia Sportage 2wd 2dr conv. | Toyota RAV4 Soft Top 2wd 2dr | Jeep Cherokee S 2wd 2dr | Isuzu Rodeo S 2wd 4dr |
Group 2 | Mitsubishi Montero Sport ES 2wd 4dr | Chevrolet Blazer 2wd 2dr | Honda CRV LX 2wd (front) 4dr | GMC Jimmy 2wd 2dr |
Group 3 | Ford Explorer Sport 2wd 2dr | Toyota 4-Runner 2wd 4dr | Chevrolet Tahoe 2wd 2dr | Nissan Pathfinder XE 2wd 4dr |
Group 4 | Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 2wd 4dr | Dodge Durango 2wd SLT 5.2 V8 4dr | Mercury Mountaineer 2wd 4dr | Ford Expedition 2wd XLT 4dr |
Please scroll down to view:
Group 5 | Oldsmobile Bravada | Lexus RX-300 2wd (front) 4dr | Mercedes ML320 | Lincoln Navigator 2wd 4dr |
Carvalu.com™ SCROLL DOWN COMPARISON CHART WITH ROUNDED DOLLAR FIGURES (*) Copyright 1988-2010 Tommy Vig --Group Five of Five |
||||
Oldsmobile Bravada | Lexus RX-300 2wd (front) 4dr | Mercedes ML320 | Lincoln Navigator 2wd 4dr | |
Retail Price (MSRP) | $31,100 | $32,000 | $35,000 | $40,700 |
Wholesale Price (Invoice) | $28,100 | $27,630 | $30,400 | $34,500 |
Destination Charge | $530 | $500 | $600 | $650 |
Dealer Hold Back (Approximate) | $930 | $0 | $1,050 | $1,220 |
Value Per Professionals' Consensus (**) (+ / -) | $29,560 = [-$1540] | $31,990 = [-$10] | $34,820 = [-$180] | $36,870 = [-$3830] |
"Honest" Base Price ™ (***) - Rating / Rank | $32,440 (4.5% advantage +$1,340) / 1st | $30,370 (4.5% disadv -$1,630) / tied for 7th | $32,150 (8% disadvantage -$2,850) / 14th | $37,810 (7% disadvantage -$2,890) / 10th |
YOUR VALUE™ ~ see interactive WIP pie | ||||
TRUE VALUE™ ~ see interactive WIP pie | ||||
I. PERFORMANCE | ||||
0-60 mph acceleration (seconds) | 9.9 | 9.1 | 9.0 | 9.9 |
Acceleration - Rating / Rank | 0.6% qiucker than average / tied for 12th | 8.6% quickier than average / 8th | 9.6% qiucker than average / tied for 6th | 0.6% quicker than average / tied for 12th |
All Wheel Drive | four wheel drive | no | yes | no |
"Attitude" | More Truck-like | More Car-like | More Car-like | More Truck-like |
Cylinders | 6 | 6 | 6 | 8 |
Cylinders- Rating / Rank | 5.3% more than average / tied for 5th (w/8) | 5.3% more than average / tied for 5th (w/8) | 5.3% more than average / tied for 5th (w/8) | 40.4% more than average / tied for 1st (w/3) |
Displacement in Cubic Inches (ci) | 262 | 183 | 195 | 330 |
Displacement - Rating / Rank | 21% larger than average / tied for 5th (w/2) | 15.5% smaller than average / 13th | 9.9% smaller than average / 12th | 52.4% larger than average / 2nd |
Engine Location / Drive Wheels | front / four wheel drive | front / front | front / all-wheel drive | front / rear |
Engine Type | 4.3L V6 | 3.0L V6 | 3.2L V6 | 5.4L V8 |
EPA Classification | SPURR4WD | WAGON - MID | SPURP4WD | SPURP2WD |
4-Wheel Drive | yes | no | all wheel drive | no |
Fuel Delivery System | SEFI | SPFI | SEFI | SEFI |
Ground Clearance (inches) | 7.5 | 7.7 | 8.4 | 8.5 |
Handling and Driveability - Rating / Rank | 11.6% below average / 17th | 5.2% below average / tied for 12 (w/3) | 22.1% better than average / 1st | 5.2% below average / tied for 12th (w/2) |
Horsepower | 190 | 220 | 215 | 300 |
Horsepower - Rating / Rank | 2.6% more than average / tied for 9th (w/2) | 18.8% more than average / 5th | 16.1 more than average / 6th | 62% more than average / 1st |
Maximum Allowable Weight | 5,360 lbs. | 4,950 lbs. | 6,005 lbs. | 6,950 lbs. |
Maximum Allowable Weight Rating / Rank | 6% more than average / 7th | 2.1% less than average / 10th | 18.8 % more than average / 5th | 37.5% more than average / 2nd |
Off Road Ability - Rating / Rank | 22.6% better than average / 5th (w/3) | 38.7% below average / tied for 16th | 22.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/3) | 16.8% below average / 13th |
Overall Performance - Rating / Rank | 17.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/3) | 56.9% better than average / 2nd | 76.5% better than average / 1st | 2% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/2) |
Payload (lbs.) | 1232 | 1161 | 1684 | 1800 |
Payload Rating / Rank | 2.6% less than average / 8th | 8.2% less than average / 10th | 33.2% more than average / 4th | 42.4% more than average / teid for 2nd |
Reviewers' Recommendation - Rating / Rank | 20% less than average / tied for 12th (w/3) | 44% more than average / 2nd | 52% more than average / #1 | 12% less than average / 11th |
Standard Transmission | automatic 4 speed | automatic 4 speed | automatic 5 speed | automatic 4 speed |
Steering | recirc | rack & pinion | rack & pinion | recirc |
Stroke | 88.4 | n/p (not published) | 84 | 105.8 |
Suspension (Front / Rear) | independent / live | independent / independent | independent / independent | independent / independent |
Top Speed | 120 mph | 115 mph | 115mph | 117 mph |
Top Speed-Rating / Rank | 9.5% faster than average / tied for 1st | 4.9% faster than average / tied for 7th (w/3) | 4.9% faster than average / tied for 7th (w/3) | 6.8% faster than average / tied for 4th (w/2) |
Torque | 250 @ 7,800 | 222 @ 4,400 | 233 @ 3,000 | 355 @ 2,750 |
Tow Capacity / Hauling (lbs.) | 5,000 | 3,500 | 5,000 | 6,600 |
Tow Capacity / Hauling-Rating / Rank | 40.8% more than average / tied for 4th (w/2) | 1.4% less than average / tied for 10th | 40.8% more than average / tied for 4th (w/2) | 85.9% more than average / 1st |
Trailering Equipment | yes | no | yes | no |
Transmission Quality - Rating / Rank | 13.7% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/6) | 15.1% better than average / tied for 1st (w/7) | 15.1% better than average / tied for 1st (w/7) | 15.1% better than average / tied for 1st (w/7) |
Valves | 12 | 24 | 18 | 32 |
Valves - Rating / Rank | 22.6% less than average / tied for 13th (w/6) | 54.8% more than the avg / 2nd | 16.1% more than the avg / 3rd | 106.5% more than the average / 1st |
Weight Distribution Front / Rear | 54 / 46 | 59 / 41 | 50 / 50 | n/p |
II. RELIABILITY | ||||
Battery - Rating / Rank | 4.3% less than average / tied for 12th (w/3) | 6.1% more than average / tied for 9th (w/2) | 36.2% less than average / 19th | 18.5% more than average / tied for 1st (w/3) |
Battery Amps | 525 | 582 | 350 | 650 |
Cold Climate Package | n/p | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Frequency of Repair - Rating / Rank | average / 13th | 11.1 % better than average / tied for 4th (w/3) | 19.4% worse than average / 16th | 11.1 % better than average / tied for 4th (w/3) |
General - Rating / Rank | 5% worse than avg / tied for 13th | 20% better than avg / #1 | 6% worse than avg / tied for 15th ( w/4) | 2% better than avg / tied for 7th |
Number of Complaints - Rating / Rank | 127.4% more (worse) than avg / 19th | 94.5% more (worse) than avg / 16th | 24.7% less (better) than avg / 12th | 87.7% more (worse) than avg / 15th |
Model Year of Production | 4th | 1st | 2nd | 2nd |
Recalls - Rank | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) | 18th | tied for 1st (w/11) (no recalls) | 20th |
Reputation of Manufacturer - Rating / Rank | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 40.6% better than average / 2nd | 56.3% better than average / 1st | 6.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) |
III. SAFETY | ||||
60 mph-0 Braking Distance (feet) | 147 ft | 145 ft | 139 ft | 149 ft |
60 mph-0 Braking Distance - Rating / Rank | 2.5% better than average / 10th | 3.8% better than average / 7th | 7.8% better than average / 5th | 1.1% better than average / 12th |
Anti-lock Brake System (ABS) | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Auto Leveling Suspension System | n/p | n/p | n/p | yes |
Brakes (Front / Rear) | disc/disc | disc/disc | disc/disc | disc/disc |
Brake Quality - Rating / Rank | 1% better than average / tied for 10th | 12.4% better than average / tied for 5th | 14.3% better than average / 2nd | 23.8% worse than average / 20th |
Bumper Strength | poor | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Cargo Net | no | yes | no | yes |
Curb Weight (lbs.) | 4049 | 3692 | 4387 | 5177 |
Curb Weight Rank | 7th | 10th | 4th | 1st |
Day / Night Rear View Mirror | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Daylight Running Lights | yes | yes | no | no |
Driver Air Bag | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Dual Note Horn | no | no | no | yes |
First Aid Kit | no | no | yes | no |
Fog Lights | yes | no | yes | yes |
Front, Back, & Side Visibility - Rating / Rank | 0.9 % better than avg. / tied for 10th (w/6) | 15.4% better than average / tied for 1st (w/5) | 8.1% better than average / tied for 8th | .9% better than average / tied for 10th (w/6) |
Global Position / Navigation System (GPS) | no | no | no | no |
Halogen Headlights | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Height (inches) | 64.2 | 65.7 | 69.9 | 75.2 |
Insurance Company Rating / Rank | 56.3% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/7) | 21.9% worse than avg / tied for 9th (w/8) | 21.9% worse than avg / tied for 9th (w/8) | 21.9% worse than avg / tied for 9th (w/8) |
Length (inches) | 183.7 | 180.1 | 180.6 | 204.8 |
Maneuverability - Rating / Rank | 9.2% better than average / tied for 4th (w/7) | 37.6% worse than average / tied for 18th | 40.5% better than average / 1st | 9.2% better than average / tied for 4th (w/7) |
NHTSA, etc. Frontal Crash Test Results-R/R | 0.9% better than average / tied for 10th (w/2) | n/p | 32% better than average / 1st | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) |
Occupant Injury Statistics Rating | 58.2% better than avg / tied for 1st (w//2) | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Overall Size - Rating / Rank | 0.9% smaller than average / 11th | 0.4% smaller than average / 9th | 1.3% larger than average / 7th | 13% larger than average / 1st |
Passenger Air Bag | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Brakes | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Reverse Sensing System | no | no | no | no |
Road Holding Index | 0.73 | 0.71 | 0.74 | 0.64 |
Road Holding Index - Rating / Rank | 2.8% better than average / 5th | average / tied for 8th | 4.2% better than average / 5th | 9.9% worse than average / 20th |
Side Air Bag | no | yes | yes | no |
Side Crash Protect | no | no | no | yes |
Skid Plates | no | no | no | no |
Spare Tire Type | fullsize | fullsize | fullsize | fullsize |
Stability Bars (Front/Rear) (inches) | 1.30 / 0.91 | 0.67 / 0.51 | n/p | 1.34 / 0.83 |
Theft Deterrent System | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Theft Frequency | n/p | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Tires | 235 / 70R-15 | 235 / 70R-16 | 255 / 65R-16 | 245 / 75R-16 |
Tires Quality Rating / Rank | 22.5% worse than average / 18th | 16.3% better than avg. / tied for 2nd (w/3) | 32.2% worse than average / 19th | 3.1% worse than average / tied for 12th (w/5) |
Traction (Front / Rear) | 57.2 / 55.1 | 61.6 / 61 | 60.4 / 60.4 | 65.4 / 65.5 |
Traction Control | yes | no | yes | no |
Wheelbase (inches) | 107 | 103.1 | 111 | 119 |
Width (inches) | 67.8 | 71.5 | 72.2 | 79.9 |
IV. COMFORT | ||||
Air Cleaning | no | no | yes | no |
Air Conditioning | yes | yes | yes | yes |
AM / FM Radio | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Arm Rests | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Automatic Climate Control | yes | no | no | yes |
Automatic Headlights | yes | yes | no | yes |
Automatic Parking Brake Release | n/p | n/p | n/p | n/p |
Automatic Seat Belts | no | no | no | no |
Availability of Parts - Rating / Rank | 34.4% better than avg / 7th | 94.7% worse than avg / 20th | 85% worse than avg / 19th | 24.8% worse than avg / 11th |
Bucket Seats | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Built In Cupholders | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Cargo Tie Down Hooks | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Cassette Player | yes | yes | yes | yes |
CD Player | yes | no | no | no |
Chime Headlights On Warning | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Chrome Grill | no | no | no | yes |
Console Operation - Rating / Rank | 4.7% better than average / tied for 6th (w/7) | 27.8% worse than average / 20th | 4.7% better than average / tied for 6th (w/7) | 19.9% better than average / 1st |
Contour - Rating / Rank | 6.5% better than average / tied for 7th (w/10) | 49.5% better than average / 1st | 30.8% better than average / tied for 2nd | 6.5% better than average / tied for 7th (w/10) |
Cruise Control | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Dealership Experience - Rating / Rank | 23% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/3) | 23% better than average / tied for 3rd (w/3) | 30% better than average / 2nd | 39% better than average / #1 |
Decor - Rating / Rank | 1.4% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 12.7% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/3) | 12.7% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/3) | 26.8% better than average / 1st |
Digital Clock | yes | no | yes | yes |
Driver Side Express Window | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Driving Range - Rating / Rank | 18.1% shorter than average / 20th | 6.5% shorter than average / tied for 14th | 8.7% shorter than average / 17th | 13.8% longer than average / 4th |
Driving Range (miles) | 324 | 370 | 361 | 450 |
Dual Temperature Air Conditioning | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Ease of Getting In & Out - Rating / Rank | 1.3% worse than average / 11th | 7.6% better than average / tied for 6th (w/3) | 43.5% better than average / 1st | 25.6% better than average / tied for 2nd |
Engine Heater | no | no | no | no |
Environmental Concerns - Rating / Rank | 10% worse than average / tied for 15th | 7.5% better than average / 6th | 5% worse than average / 13th | 25% worse than average / 20th |
Ergonomics - Rating / Rank | 7.2% better than average / tied for 9th (w/2) | 14.4% better than average / 2nd | 8.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/3) | 7.2% better than average / tied for 9th (w/2) |
Fuel Capacity (gallons) | 18 gal | 17.2 gal | 19 gal | 30 gal |
Glass Tint | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Head Rests | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Heated Seats | yes | no | no | no |
Heated Side Mirror | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Illuminated Entry System | yes | no | yes | yes |
Illuminated Vanity Mirrors | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Instrument Panel Layout & Quality - Rating / Rank | 3.8% better than average / tied for 7th (w/2) | 17.6% better than average / 3rd | 3.8% better than average / tied for 7th (w/2) | 7.3% better than average / 6th |
Interior & Exterior Noise - Rating / Rank | 5% quieter than average / 9th | 33.7% quieter than average / tied for 3rd | 33.7% quieter than average / tied for 3rd | 38.4% quieter than average / 2nd |
Keyless Entry | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Leather Seats / Upholstery | yes | no | no | yes |
Leather Wrapped Steering Wheel | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Luggage Rack | yes | no | yes | yes |
Map Lights | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Map Pockets | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Memory System for Seats, Mirrors, Radio, etc. | no | no | no | yes |
Number Of Dealerships | 2,840 | 111 | 316 | 1,589 |
Number Of Dealerships Rating / Rank | 34.4% more than average / 7th | 94.7% less than average / 20th | 85% less than average / 19th | 24.8% less than average / 11th |
Percent of All Dealerships | 12.3% | 0.5% | 1.4% | 6.9% |
Power Accessory Outlet(s) | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Adjustable Pedals with Memory | no | no | no | yes |
Power Antenna | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Door Locks | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Lumbar Support | yes | yes | no | yes |
Power Mirrors | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Seats | yes | yes | no | yes |
Power Steering | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Steering Cooler | no | no | yes | yes |
Power Trunk / Hood / Gas Cap | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Power Windows | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Rear Audio Controls & Headphone Jacks | no | no | no | yes |
Rear Defogger | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Rear Seat Ventilation | yes | yes | no | yes |
Rear Wiper / Washer | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Ride Quality - Rating / Rank | 19.2% better than average / 3rd | 15% better than average / 5th | 12.9% better than average / 6th | 25.4% better than average / 2nd |
Running Boards | yes | no | no | yes |
Sliding Rear Window | no | no | no | yes |
Sound System Quality - Rating / Rank | 11.3% better than average / 7th | 3.9% better than average / tied for 8th (w/3) | 18.7% better than average / tied for 2nd (w/4) | 3.9% better than average / tied for 8th (w/3) |
Spare Tire Cover | no | no | no | no |
Sunroof / Moonroof | no | no | no | no |
Telephone | no | no | no | no |
Tilt / Telescopic Steering | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Trunk Cargo Organizer | no | no | no | no |
Turning Cycle - Curb to Curb | 39.5 | 41.3 | 37 | 40.4 |
Turning Cycle - Rating / Rank | 5.9% worse than average / 16th | 10.7% worse than average / 20th | 0.8% better than average / 10th | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 17th |
Two-tone Paint | no | no | no | no |
Universal Garage Door Opener | yes | no | yes | no |
Variable Assist Steering | yes | no | yes | yes |
Wheels | alloy | alloy | alloy | alloy |
White Design Tires | no | no | no | no |
Wood Interior Trim | no | yes | no | yes |
V. ROOMINESS | ||||
Cargo Volume - Rating / Rank | 4.2% smaller than average / 12th | 3.1% smaller than average / 11th | 10.4% bigger than average / 5th | 50.4% bigger than average / 2nd |
Cargo Volume (cubic feet) | 74.2 | 75.1 | 85.5 | 116.5 |
Driver/Passenger Room-Rate/Rank | 4.3% bigger than average / tied for 5th | 1.4% bigger than average / tied for 9th | 7.9% bigger than average / 4th | 37.8% bigger than average / 1st |
Head Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 39.6 / 38.3 | 39.5 / 39.2 | 39.8 / 39.7 | 39.8 / 39.8 |
Hip Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 53.6 / 51.3 | 55.2 / 55.2 | 55 / 54.6 | 61.2 / 62.3 |
Leg Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 42.4 / 36.3 | 40.7 / 36.4 | 40.3 / 38 | 41 / 39.7 |
Passenger Number (Seating) | 5 | 5 | 5 | 7 |
Passenger Number Rating / Rank | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 5.7% less than average / tied for 4th (w/14) | 32.1% more than average / tied for 2nd |
Rear Folding Seats | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Shoulder Room (Front / Rear) (cu in.) | 57.1 / 57.2 | 57.8 / 57 | 58.3 / 57.9 | 63.8 / 64.4 |
Storage Compartments-Rating/Rank | 23.6% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/7) | 22.7% worse than average / 18th | 23.6% better than avg / tied for 1st (w/7) | 8.2% better than average / 9th |
VI. EXPERTS' CONSENSUS (****) | ||||
Average of Overall Rating / Rank | 5% disadvantage to list price / tied for 14th | 0.03% disadvantage to list price / 5th | 0.5% disadvantage to list price / 6th | 9.4% disadvantage to list price / 19th |
VII. POPULARITY | ||||
Customer Satisfaction - Rating / Rank | 40% worse than average / tied for 18th | average / tied for 6th (w/8) | average / tied for 6th (w/8) | average / tied for 6th (w/8) |
Fashionableness - Rating / Rank | 5.8% less than average / 13th | 8.7% more than average / tied for 6th (w/3) | 20.3% less than average / 18th | 15.9% more than avg / tied for 3rd (w/2) |
1997 / 1998 Sales | 28,481 / 30,202 | not made / 42,191 | 14,569 / 36,596 (incl. ML 430) | 43,859 / 43,859 |
1998 Sales - Rating / Rank | 73.7% less than average / 19th | 63.2% less than average / 16th | 68.1% less than average / 18th | 61.8% less than average / 15th |
Popularity Rank in its Price Range | 5th | 3rd | 4th (incl. ML430) | 2nd |
Sales Trend - Rating / Rank | 6% rise / 11th | first year in production | 196.1% rise / 2nd | 63.5% rise / 3rd |
Status Symbol - Rating / Rank | 36.4% higher than average / tied for 4th | 51.5% higher than avg / tied for 1st (w/2) | 51.5% higher than avg / tied for 1st (w/2) | 51.5% higher than avg / tied for 1st (w/2) |
VIII. ECONOMY | ||||
Basic Warranty | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 48 months / 50,000 | 48 months / 50,000 | 48 months / 50,000 |
Basic Warranty - Rating / Rank | 5% below average / tied for 5th (w/15) | 26% better than average / tied for 1st (w/2) | 26% better than average / tied for 1st (w/2) | 26% better than average / tied for 1st (w/2) |
Fuel Economy City / Highway mpg | 16 / 20 (Avg 18) | 19 / 24 (Avg 21.5) | 17 / 21 (Avg 19) | 13 / 17 (Avg 15) |
Fuel Economy - Rating / Rank | 10% worse than average / tied for 15th | 7.5% better than average / 6th | 5% worse than average / 13th | 25% worse than average / 20th |
True Fuel Economy (per weight) - Rating / Rank | 3.7% worse than average / tied for 10th (w/7) | 3.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) | 11.1% better than average / 3rd | 3.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/5) |
Included Equipment - Rating / Rank | 165% more thana verage / 1st | 35.3% more than average / tied for 7th | 15.1% less than average / 14th | 0.7% less than average / 10th |
Overall Warranty - Rating / Rank | 10.7% worse than avg / tied for 13th (w/3) | 31% better than average / 1st | 16.7% worse than average / 20th | 14.8% better than average / 2nd |
Per Mile Cost of Operation - Rating / Rank | 26.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/4) | 74.7% worse than average / tied for 18th (w/2) | 26.6% better than average / tied for 5th (w/4) | 74.7% worse than average / tied for 18th (w/2) |
Powertrain Warranty | 36 months / 36,000 miles | 72 months / 70,000 miles | 48 months / 50,000 | 48 months / 50,000 |
Resale Value - Rating / Rank | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) | 8.3% worse than average / tied for 6th (w/11) |
Roadside Assistance - Rating / Rank | 8.7% better than average / tied for 4th (w/10) | 30.4% better than average / 2nd | 73.9% better than average / 1st | 19.6% better than average / 3rd |
Rust Warranty | 72 months / 100,000 miles | 72 months / unlimited mileage | 48 months / 50,000 | 60 months / unlimited mileage |
(*) | Equipment included in base price. |
(**) | Professionals’ Consensus: Carvalu.com™’s monetary interpretation of published evaluations. |
(***) | “Honest” Base Price™: What the price should be, based solely on included equipment. No dishonesty is implied. |
(****) | Per Carvalu.com™ interpretation. |
Important Notes: | |
1. | Our dollar figures (i.e. Value Per Professionals’ Consensus™, “Honest” Base Price™ , Your Value™, True Value™, Your Pick™, etc.) exclude, among others, Hold Back, Destination Charge, Tax, License, Title, Fun to Drive, Pride of Ownership, |
Prestige Value, Panache, Presence, and only relate to the published Base Price of the identified model. | |
2. | All our calculation formulas are patented and patent pending, proprietary processes and resulting dollar figures express Carvalu.com™ opinions based on our research and unique methodology. |
3. | Ratings, rankings, and percentage denotions are based on Carvalu.com™ patented and patent pending calculation formulas and are determined by comparing vehicles in this field of 20 SUVs; including interpreting ratings by experts who tested |
the vehicles. | |
4. | SUVs are generally more expensive to repair than cars. In this group of 20, at a 5 mph crash, The Montero Sport is the costliest to fix, while the Mercedes ML 320 has the lowest repair bill. |
5. | All entries relate strictly to 1999 base models. SUVs depreciate less than passenger cars, but there is less room for bargaining when buying a new one. Close cousins are: 1) Blazer, Jimmy, and Bravada; 2) Expedition and Navigator; 3) Explorer and Mountaineer |
6. | n/p = not published |
7. | Please see propietary calculation page for True $ Value™. True $ Value™ mirrors the judgment of the hypothetical optimally informed contemporary society, or answers the question: What would the community say this SUV is worth today if it suddenly knew everything it wanted to know about SUVs? Proprietary Carvalu.com™ calculation method is patented and patent pending. |
8. | Please see proprietary Carvalu.com™ calculation page for Your $ Value™. Your $ Value™ mirrors your own estimate as if by magic you were ideally knowledgeable about SUVs in your very own terms. Of course, you must first give your ratings of relative importance 0 – 10, 10 being most important, to the computer’s quiz regarding the eight abbreviated value affecting factors: Performance, Reliability, Safety, Comfort, Roominess, Experts’ Consensus, Popularity, and Economy. |
9. | MSRP is the manufacturer-suggested retail price of the base model as equipped at the factory. |
10. | Invoice is the estimated cost of the dealer for the factory equipped base model. |
11. | Carvalu.com™ wholesale (Invoice) figures consistently exclude hold backs, incentives, advertising costs, overhead expenses, and so on, as they always vary. |
12. | At present, Carvalu.com™ included more than 200 sub-elements contained in the eight main value-affecting groups. Under Qualities’ Inventory, we provide a brief description of what some of these particulars actually do for the driver. |
13. | When driving an SUV, avoid excessive speed and abrupt maneuvers to guard against roll-overs. |
14. | Carvalu.com™ employs the proprietary calculation formulas of the new scienceNon-Subjective Valuing®which is validated by both the Innovation Institute (recommended by the United States Department of Commerce) and the PTO. Unlike other consumer guides, our unique website provides the user with scientifically calculated dollar value numbers, independent of price. We leave vague approximations, unquantified specs and stats provided in a vacuum, and subjective ratings without a universal yardstick to other shopping directories. Please be aware of and alert us to imitators of our patented and patent pending system who might masquerade as providing scientifically sound dollar value numbers, but who really do not. |
15. | Please read the Visitor Agreement containing the terms of the contract governing your use of this site. |
16. | Braking distances and other numbers do not necessarily express quality differences, since vehicle size and other respective relevant facts are not always taken into consideration at this time. |
17. | (w/#) = number of other cars with which this vehicle received identical ranking. |
18. | In the long experience of the inventor of patented and patent pending Non-Subjective Valuing® most of us will not admit, even to ourselves, how important the value of status symbol is to us. As a result, for now, Carvalu.com™ leaves that often decisive quality to the user to measure. We, however, hold that prestige value is real value, and paying for that value is perfectly OK. |
19. | Experts’ Consensus is Carvalu.com™ interpretation of combined professional opinion. |
20. | Print horizontally for best results. |
21. | The above is data for the 1999 models. This is a general example illuminating the Non-Subjective Valuing® patented methodology. |
- Registration / Login
- Try Our System If you are interested and want to see how it works...
- Calculate the Current Monetary Value of a Specific Automobile
- Non-Subjective Valuing® All about the method that Carvalu.com™ uses...
- FAQ Frequently Asked Questions
- Philosophy Value and Price
- Practical Buying Idea How to make the best possible new supermini deal
- "Honest" Base Price Concerning "honest" base price and other novel numbers...
- Improving Democracy Improving the free market system by eliminating asymmetric information
- Status Symbol Prestige value has real monetary worth
- Comparison Charts Carvalu.com™ Qualities' Inventory
- Value Comparison Carvalu.com™ Novel Comparison Chart
- Theft of Intellectual Property?
- Visitor Agreement Disclaimers, Philosophy, and Explanations
- Technical Support
- Home